Winter Rubber 15 Radius Studded Test. Nitto Therma Spike: Japanese calculation. Production and design

the main / Butter

Trying to consolidate in the US market, the Japanese company Toyo Tire in 1995 created the Nitto brand. The enterprise products were intended solely for powerful premium sedans, sports cars and SUVs. Gradually sales started in Europe and Russia.

The company's line has different types of tires. Among the drivers, the winter model Nitto Therma Spike uses in great demand. Reviews of the presented rubber in most cases are only positive.

Production and design

The model was created with the active application of various technological innovations. For example, the design of the tread was designed using digital simulation methods. After creating the prototype, engineers started testing at the Toyo polygon. Only after bringing the model to perfection under these conditions, the tires were allowed into the series. Multi-level quality control, certified ISO, eliminates the risks of acquiring a retail of defective tires Nitto Therma Spike. Motorists testify that the quality of tires is consistently high.

Tread design

It is worth mentioning that the concern moved from the adopted canons in the design of winter tires. Tires received a revolutionary asymmetrical tread pattern. The outer part is quite large, consists of large quadrangular blocks. Massive elements retain their resistance with sharp deformation loads. As a result, the vehicle maintains stability during the passage of turns and in braking.

During the tests of Nitto Therma Spike, it turned out that the presented sample of the tire allows you to maintain a motorist phenomenally high speed of maneuvers. Wheels quickly respond to any changes in the steering.

The inner part gives stability with rectilinear motion. The vehicle is well holding the road, demolitions during the speed set are missing in principle.

Two compound

The outer and inner parts of the winter tires Nitto Therma Spike are different not only by design, but also by the type of rubber mixture. In the first case, a tougher composition is used. It is it that allows you to preserve the necessary maneuverability and the quality of movement. In the second, manufacturers in the compound increased the share of elastomers. As a result, the tire behave more gently, do not provoke high shaking in the cabin when moving through a bad road surface.

The use of special compounds allows you to expand and temperature operation. Tires retain their elasticity even in a heavy frost. Reviews of Nitto Therma Spike drivers argue that the rubber of this class is able to withstand extremely low temperatures.

Behavior on ice

During test test tests, Nitto Therma Spike showed almost perfect ice behavior. The clutch quality is high due to important technical solutions.

  1. First, spikes are located in 14 rows. This allows preventing the formation of a rut effect. The car retains his maneuverability even on the glaced tracks.
  2. Secondly, the spike head has a variable cross section. Such an unusual approach allows to maintain the stability of turning and braking. Demolitions are absent in principle.
  3. Thirdly, special small notches are applied to the tread blocks. As a result, the rigidity of all elements increases, the total number of clutch edges increases.

Snow and water removal

Reviews of Nitto Therma Spike drivers mark and stability ride on a wet road. The negative effect of hydroplating, formed due to the occurrence of the micropoline of water between the tire and the road, is completely absent. This is implemented thanks to a number of measures. For example, Nitto Therma Spike tires received a developed drainage system. The liquid quickly enters the longitudinal channels, then it is redistributed over the entire tire and removal from the contact spot. Improve the clutch quality allows the increased proportion of silicon dioxide used in the compilation of the compound.

The dimensions of the drainage tubules allow the tires to quickly remove the snow hinged on the protector. It just cleans with the depths of the tread under his own severity.

Durability

In reviews of Nitto Therma Spike drivers celebrate and high enough mileage. Tires can withstand about 75 thousand km run. Naturally, the ultimate figure largely depends on the style of the motorist control. After installing the wheels, it is necessary about 1 thousand km to overcome in the most gentle mode. The driver must avoid high speeds and sharp braking. This will allow the spike to be more tightly fixed in the installation places and prevent their premature loss.

Improve reliability helps the use of reinforced frame of a frame. Metal threads are binding to an elastic polymer. As a result, it is possible to more fully redistribute external deformation loads. The risk of forming cones and hernia is reduced to zero.

In the production of rubber mixture for tires NITTO THERMA SPIKE, technical carbon is actively used. The compound reduced the speed of mechanical abrasion.

The optimized distribution of external pressure leads to uniform wear of the tire. The emphasis on the central part or external is missing.

Winter studded tire. The main features declared by the manufacturer:

  • provide confident driving when maneuvering on the icing surface,
  • improve the course stability when driving in a track,
  • provide confident adhesion when overclocking and braking like ice and dry surface,
  • the non-directional asymmetric design helps the tread to be cleaned from moisture and snow porridge.

Special development for Russian winter conditions.

Results of the test 195/65 R15 "Polem" 2018

821 score ,.
Number of spikes: 119.
Tire weight: 8.95 kg.
Speaking of spikes after the test: 1.4 ... 1.7 mm.

Satisfactory handling.
+ Not bad permeability.
+ Acceptable smoothness.

These tires are economical, provide an average level of comfort ... and last place on the asphalt.

Review of experts "Autores" 2016: 185/65 R15

8.1 points ,.
Number of spikes: 115.
Tire weight: 8.5 kg.
Speakers of spikes: 1.4 mm.
The depth of the tread pattern: 9 mm.

    Pros:
  • longitudinal coupling properties on ice,
  • ease of control in the snow.
    Disadvantages:
  • coupling properties on asphalt,
  • low resistance to aquaplaning,
  • loss of spikes.

The Nitto brand belongs to the Japanese Toyo Tires company. And this is not the second, but rather a parallel line.

Nitto tires are distinguished by catchy extraordinary design. Here in the stack of winter tires for them immediately clings to the look - for an asymmetric pattern, for a diamond-shaped scheme of obychi.

And such a scheme works: on the coupling property on the ice Nitto in the top three leaders! But on the run of the controllability, these tires endow the car with a tendency to drift: in steep turns, well, and on the running arcs of the silent of the rear axle inappropriate.

In the snow, the average indicators, but on the asphalt coupling properties leave much to be desired, exactly as the resistance to aquapalnation. But it is even worse that by the end of the tests on one of the tires we were not subject to ten spikes. Yes, and in the rest one or two empty holes.

Good tires for winter coatings, but aggressive ride on asphalt them is contraindicated.

In the next large test of "Shipovok" we collected six kits of 15-inch tires from Western and Eastern manufacturers. Some among the visa is the experience and the latest technologies, others have the will to victory and affordable prices. Whose will take?

This time we chose one of the most running dimensions - 195/65 R15, which suits many small and inexpensive cars. Different markets, different understanding of the product, different design schools. What distinguishes the tires from the east and west apart from each other, what are their strengths and weaknesses and what to pay attention to the Russian buyer?

Fresh model Bridgestone Blizzak Spike-02 - Maja dear in the East Team (price 3650 rubles), but cheaper than European chanda.

Another novelty, Hankook Winter I * Pike RS 2, - tire with an increased number of spikes and an updated tread pattern. It replaces the Winter I * Pike RS model. This year will appear in Russia in 57 dimensions - from 155/65r 13 to 255/40 R19.

The new Toyo Observe Ice- Freezer bus came to a change of the OBSERVE G3-ICE model and will be available on the market in this fall until 16 sizes are from 14 to 19 inches. The rubber mixture includes silicon dioxide, providing elasticity in the cold, and microparticles of walnut shell for additional clutch on ice.

Another model with Japanese roots is now produced in Russia - Firestone Ice Cruiser 7. Previously, this tire wore an index 7000 and belonged to the BRIDGESTONE brand line.

The next player from Japan - Nitto Therma Spike, Relative Brand Toyo. These tires take part in our tests a second time and are characterized as inexpensive, with modest characteristics.

The new tire GT Radial Icepro 3, who came to the change of the GT Radial Champiro Icepro model, is designed in its own research and development center in Hannover. A brand GT Radial belongs to the developing international Giti company based in Singapore. The novelty is available in 22 dimensions - from 175/65 R14 to 225/60 R17.

Tires participating in the test are produced in China.

West

There are no new products in the Western team, but the players are incredibly strong, since most of these tire manufacturers are updated annually.

Nokian Hakkapeliitta 9, the most expensive tire in the domestic market, is the only one in the world has the spikes of two different types.

Continental IceContAct 2 is also the only and unique: its "carnations" is glued into the protector, and therefore it is very firmly held in it.

From tires cheaper - Goodyear Ultragrip Ice Arctic, more than once occupied prizes in our tests, and Pirelli Ice Zero.

Close the composition of the Western team of two direct competitor, representatives of the second echelon of Continental and Nokian companies - respectively, the Gislaved Nord * Frost 200 and Nordman 7 models.

On the track of the estimates of controllability on ice after each set of tires, the "brush" cleans the coating from the ice crumb. The cleaner the ice, the more accurate the results of the assessment.

cat house

Roulette, annually determining the place of our tests of winter tires, this time pointed to the Continental polygon. It is located in Sweden, next to the small town with the purrious-rigorous name Arvidskore - directly some "Koshkin House".

Mighting last year's weather Apocalypse in Sweden with sudden February warming, they decided to begin the tests early - in mid-January.

And the weather did not fail: during testing stood frosts from -7 to -14 ° C.

In the tests, two hatchback Volkswagen Golf helped us. On the black we laid the main part of the routine work - it chopped on ice and snow, fixing the built-in VBox instrument time acceleration and the magnitude of the braking path. Red performed more creative tasks, participating in evaluating manageability and coursework stability, since it could completely disable the stabilization system using a special program.

Black work for driving

The first to work is a black Golf, which also involves the anti-lock system, and the anti-duct. We begin with overclocking and braking on ice on a small frozen lake, repeating the races of eight or ten times for each tire set. Through two or three test sets - measurements on basic (reference, as shinniki say) tires: without them do not do.

Measures on different coatings differ in the "upper" high-speed limit, which serves as the maximum value of speed during acceleration and initial - when braking. On Ice, this value is 20 km / h, and in the snow - 40 km / h, as a modest ice area is much less snowy. Recalling the results, taking into account the amendments defined using reference tires, we obtain leaders and outsiders in these exercises.

A real surprise issued a plan that broke the traditional leaders. Incredibly, but on these tires Golf accelerates and slows down on the ice even better than on continental and Nokian. To overclock the place up to 20 km / h, the Hankook tires took only 4.1 seconds, and the braking path from 20 to 5 km / h was 6.6 meters. The most protracted acceleration turned out on the tires Gislaved: 5.9 seconds. Close result, 5.8 seconds, obtained on the GT Radial and Firestone tires. Worst of all Golf slowed down on the GT Radial tires: the brake path was 8.7 meters.

The fastest acceleration in the snow is up to 40 km / h provided the Continental tires with an indicator of 5.9 seconds, and Hankook lost them only one tenth! Six all - GT Radial tires.

In braking on the snow cover, Hankook broke forward. To slow down the Golf from 40 to 5 km / h, this tires were enough 16.9 meters. Second place - Gislavda: 17.2 meters. The latter in braking was Firestone and GT Radial: 19,1 and 19.0 meters, respectively.

We complete the Ice Test Series after measuring the circle time, which characterizes the transverse clutch. Continental has retained leadership by running the circle for a record 15.6 seconds. Nearest rivals - and this Hankook, Nokian and Gislaved - it took half a second more. The slower only - for 18.0 seconds - the car passed the circle on Bridgestone tires.

Rating of the best winter studded tires 2018

The tires released after measurements occupy their place on a red golf - we will evaluate the controllability on the snow cover and on the ice.

The test track is great: turns of different radius, from running to zacnyny, straight, allowing to reach the speedometer arrow up to 80 km / h, lifts and descents, then unloading wheels, then pressing them to "road".

Due to the modest dimensions of the frozen lake, we estimate overclocking ice to a speed of 20 km / h, and inhibit from 20 to 5 km / h.

12 Firestone Ice Cruiser 7

Country of manufacture

Load and speed indices

Depth of drawing in width, mm

Scor rubber hardness, units.

Number of spikes, pcs.

Tire mass, kg

Quality / price, score / p

Brake properties level on dry asphalt medium

11 GT Radial Icepro 3

Country of manufacture

Load and speed indices

Depth of drawing in width, mm

Scor rubber hardness, units.

Number of spikes, pcs.

Speaking of spikes after tests, mm

Tire mass, kg

Average price in online stores, p *

Quality / price, score / p

Stable following the course on the snow;

No noisy;

Satisfactory smoothness

Meager coupling properties on ice and snow;

Complex handling;

Limited permeability

10 Nittotherma Spike

Country of manufacture

Load and speed indices

Depth of drawing in width, mm

Scor rubber hardness, units.

Number of spikes, pcs.

Speaking of spikes after tests, mm

Tire mass, kg

Average price in online stores, p *

Quality / price, score / p

Satisfactory handling;

Good permeability;

Acceptable smoothness

Low brake properties on wet asphalt and ice;

Complex handling when performing an extreme maneuver on the snow and cocoic stability on asphalt;

9 TOYO OBSERVE ICE-FREEZER

Country of manufacture

Malaysia

Load and speed indices

Depth of drawing in width, mm

Scor rubber hardness, units.

Number of spikes, pcs.

Speaking of spikes after tests, mm

Tire mass, kg

Average price in online stores, p *

Quality / price, score / p

Good coupling stability in the snow;

Stable handling on ice and in the snow

Weak brake properties on ice and dry asphalt;

High fuel consumption at a speed of 90 km / h

8 Bridgestone BLIZZAK SPIKE-02

Country of manufacture

Load and speed indices

Depth of drawing in width, mm

Scor rubber hardness, units.

Number of spikes, pcs.

Speaking of spikes after tests, mm

Tire mass, kg

Average price in online stores, p *

Quality / price, score / p

Confident Patency and Satisfactory Handling in Conventional Driving in Snow

Weak braking on dry asphalt and lateral clutch on ice;

Low economy;

Complex handling in active driving in the snow;

Comments to the course stability on asphalt and comfort

7 GISLAVED NORD * FROST 200

Country of manufacture

Germany

Load and speed indices

Depth of drawing in width, mm

Scor rubber hardness, units.

Number of spikes, pcs.

Speaking of spikes after tests, mm

Tire mass, kg

Average price in online stores, p *

Quality / price, score / p

The best brake properties and excellent packed resistance on the asphalt;

Confident lateral clutch and understandable handling

Weak longitudinal coupling properties on ice;

High fuel consumption at any speed;

Complex handling when performing an extreme maneuver on the snow;

Small claims to the smoothness of the course

6 NOKIAN NORDMAN 7

Country of manufacture

Load and speed indices

Depth of drawing in width, mm

Scor rubber hardness, units.

Number of spikes, pcs.

Speaking of spikes after tests, mm

Tire mass, kg

Average price in online stores, p *

Quality / price, score / p

Confident overclocking on ice;

Good permeability, course stability in the snow and on the asphalt

5 Goodyear UltraGrip Ice Arctic

Country of manufacture

Load and speed indices

Depth of drawing in width, mm

Scor rubber hardness, units.

Number of spikes, pcs.

Speaking of spikes after tests, mm

Tire mass, kg

Average price in online stores, p *

Quality / price, score / p

Phenomenal permeability in deep snow;

High brake properties both on wet and dry asphalt

Small claims to the rate of resistance on asphalt and manageability on ice, as well as in active driving and extreme maneuvering in the snow;

Not the best comfort.

4 Pirelli Ice Zero

Country of manufacture

Load and speed indices

Depth of drawing in width, mm

Scor rubber hardness, units.

Number of spikes, pcs.

Speaking of spikes after tests, mm

Tire mass, kg

Average price in online stores, p *

Quality / price, score / p

Excellent course stability;

Reliable acceleration on ice and snow;

Understandable handling in the snow under normal driving;

Confident Patency

Easy remarks to manageability in the snow with active driving and with extreme maneuvering;

Noisy; Low smoothness stroke

2/3 Hankook Winter I * Pike RS 2

Country of manufacture

Load and speed indices

Depth of drawing in width, mm

Scor rubber hardness, units.

Number of spikes, pcs.

Speaking of spikes after tests, mm

Tire mass, kg

Average price in online stores, p *

Quality / price, score / p

The best longitudinal and high transverse clutch on ice;

Better braking and confident acceleration on snow;

Understandable handling of ice and under normal driving in the snow;

Weak braking on the asphalt;

Claims for manageability in the snow in active driving and with extreme maneuvering, as well as to the course stability on asphalt and comfort

2/3 Continental IceContAct 2

Country of manufacture

Germany

Load and speed indices

Depth of drawing in width, mm

Scor rubber hardness, units.

Number of spikes, pcs.

Speaking of spikes after tests, mm

Tire mass, kg

Average price in online stores, p *

Quality / price, score / p

Best transverse and high longitudinal 49 clutch on ice;

Best overclocking and confident braking in the snow;

Understandable handling on ice and in the snow;

Good permeability and following the course on the snow

Minor claims to manageability in the snow in active driving, as well as to the rate resistance on the asphalt;

Comments to comfort

1 Nokian HakkaPeliitta 9

Country of manufacture

Load and speed indices

Depth of drawing in width, mm

Scor rubber hardness, units.

Number of spikes, pcs.

Speaking of spikes after tests, mm

Tire mass, kg

Average price in online stores, p *

Quality / price, score / p

Outstanding fuel efficiency;

Excellent handling on ice and snow;

High coupling properties on ice;

Excellent permeability in deep snow;

Clear follower

Light notes on noise and smoothness

The idea was born to estimate the tires in two different modes of movement. The first - you go fast, but limit the speed in the corners of the initial slip phase. The results of the ride in such a style will surely become interested in most drivers. The second mode is for lovers. Slip: Almost does not reduce the speed before turning, fueling the car in the turn of sideways. We used to evaluate the behavior of the tires and in that and in other modes, only the estimate was raised averaged.

Disable electronics to catch the features of the behavior of the car on different tires.

In the usual test mode, the golf control was pleased with Nokian and Pirelli tires. Experts, not finding reasons for comments and noting clear reactions, set them eight points. Continental, Hankook, Nordman, taking into account the small remarks, received 7.5 points. It is noteworthy that golf, waged in the Hankook and Nordman tires, minor delays in reactions and insufficient steering informativeness occurs when the steering wheel turns to 90 degrees turns, but with an increase in the reaction angles and influence the corners are improved, and with Continental tires, on the contrary.

On tire tests, the command spirit is important almost as in competitions. Therefore, we change the wheels almost as quickly as mechanics in formula boxes.

"Shipovki" Firestone collected claims more than others: significant delays in reactions, unstable behavior. The driver can only ask the approximate direction of movement, but not an accurate trajectory. Six points - maximum.

With the active style of driving, almost half of the subjects marked with a small slowdown in reactions and deterioration of the steering in the transition to slip, which reduced the grabral assessment. Eight points were received only by the Nokian tires, which preserved the clarity of the reactions even in deep slides. Acceptable reaction stability was demonstrated by Gislaved, Nordman and Touo - they are not scary slightly slightly overdo the speed in slippery turn.

The easiest way to slip on the firestone tires. In the turn of Golf, it is literally literally to custody, performing a set of "witchcraft" steering and gas.

Actively go Archis post, because it is necessary to constantly twist the ram in different directions, since in slides of the reaction to the steering action, it is practically disappeared.

It was also not actively liked to go on Bridgestone (reduced the rating by 1 point) and, oddly enough, on Pirelli (reduced by one and a half points). On both tires, Golf demonstrated the deterioration of informativeness and reactions, which forcing significantly actively work with the steering wheel, and on Pirelli - also torn, unstable behavior. It is strange, because the early models of the winter tires of this company have always served for us, and for many shinniks, a reference to manageability.

The ice trail liked no less snowy. It is not horizontal, but is located under the tilt, because they are filled on the slope. Therefore, in one half, moving with time-loaded rear wheels, provoking the skid, and on the other, with the unfavorable front, initiating demolition. It helps better understand the peculiarities of the behavior of certain tires.

The highest score on ice earned Nokian: the car rulits without problems in any modes. Small blots are marked on the tires Continental, Gislaved, Hankook and Nordman, therefore their estimates are reduced to 7.5 points.

Being shown in Tires Gr Radial, Golf moves as in weightlessness - as if there are no horizontal forces. It hills up very early, although it slides in the side smoothly (this is the only plus), and floats very long, without reacting to steering actions.

Firestone holds the driver in even more voltage: the maximum of adrenaline is produced even with the stabilization system included. Frams in slip occur unexpectedly, slides the car extremely long ... There is a feeling that the clutch disappeared at all.

Caution - Yeti!

Snow Plateau is a huge rectangle, about four hundred per hundred meters, separated by the snow brushner into two independent narrow and long straight.

They are enough to accelerate to 100 km / h and evaluate the course stability and behavior of the machine with soft rebuilding.

And the widths are enough to check the handling when performing the rearrangement. From the first day, we buried the cones along the central barrier, the meter strip is three width, forbid it. A week later she accumulated a layer of snow with a depth of about 20 centimeters - what is needed to evaluate the passability.

A couple of hours after the red Golf with a disabled stabilization system went to the test track, Frank Degonir suddenly approached us (the continental engineer responsible for performing measurement and measuring equipment) and asked with an absolutely serious person:

"Do you know that here Yeti hijacked? Right in front of red golf jumped out! But Anton managed to dodge him, only the snow on the hood remained. Go look! ".

It turns out that Golf during the estimation of the term stability on Firestone tires won so that he struck the snow brush and flew to the neighboring strip. And Continental Testers Any incident on tests ending with contact with snow, name "Yeti". In general, Firestone for the course stability in the snow has earned a lower score: when you try to smoothly rebuild or throw the obstacle, a sharp drift occurs and a long slip towards without the ability to correct the trajectory. Other tires "Yeti" could not be taken.

And better than others directly in the snow at high speed Golf held on Nokian and Pirelli tires.

Rearrum, or a sharp change of strip, - maneuver, traditional for Russian drivers. When performing the rearrangement, we evaluate how Golf responds to sharp turns of the steering wheel and how predictably behaves. The maximum assessment in this exercise experts put Nokian tires: a small, well-clear, soft skid at the limiting speed, requiring minor adjustment to keep the car on the desired trajectory.

The worst and here were the tires Firestone: they are unsuitable for dangerous maneuvers. With sharp steering steering, the case ends with a demolition, straightening the trajectory. With more smooth operation, the front wheels have time to get clinging behind the snow, but the rear sharply break into a long lateral slide, spinning the car.

Patency

The test for the passability is relevant both for Russian depths and for large cities. We estimate not only the ability of tires to row in the snow, it is important how easily the driver without special skills of the off-road driving can overcome the snow barrier.

In the deep snow, Goodyear's tire is out of competition: row at least ahead, at least back, you just need to press the gas pedal. Nokian is lagging behind the Polballa: row is not tractor, but still good. Eight points earn Continental and Nordman. The most unsuccessful tires for deep snow - GT Radial. On them, Golf will be insecably touched, digs from side to side, reluctantly maneuver and reluctantly moves with reverse.

Winter hero 2018.

Tire from the East - Hankook Winter I * Pike RS 2. It is not only ahead of all countrymen in winter disciplines, but also moved "Westerners" - even such Grande as Continental and Nokian, who took the "White" tests Only a second and third place, respectively.

Pirelli - in the fourth place, then go Nordman and Goodyear, a gislaved - on the seventh position.

They are followed by other tires from the east: Bridgestone, Toyo, Nitto, as well as Firestone and GT Radial, which showed the weakest results.

Delay to spring

In mid-April, the snow completely descended from the asphalt of the high-speed road of the Vazovsky landfill near Togliatti. Choosing weak weather, we continued the tests of "riding" - now on the asphalt. The first thing was to evaluate the influence of tires on golf efficiency, aligning these measurements with an assessment of course stability and comfort.

Started from the warm-up ten-meter circle through the speed road at a speed of 130 km / h (maximum allowed on our roads). The measurements were performed on a two-kilometer horizontal direct section of the high-speed road.

In glacial weather, the results of measurements "fall" almost one to one - with no more than 0.1%, which are twenty times less generally accepted in tire tests of two percent. But every three proven sets have to repeat races on the base bus. The temperature of the asphalt is noticeably affected by rolling resistance. The results obtained on the reference bus helps to define "reference points", and already specify the data obtained and, if necessary, recalculate.

The asphalt Golf is best holding a course on Gislaved and Pirelli tires: reactions are clear, almost like summer tires. Worse than the rest - "Eastern guests" Bridgestone, Nitto and Firestone.

At Bridge, a golf handlebar was heavy, viscous and non-informative. The behavior of the car on Nitto and Firestone is similar: low informativeness is manifested in the okolonul zone, when adjusting the course, the ram has to rotate to significant corners. When leaving the Ocolone - the left zone of the reaction becomes unpleasant with sharp - with low informativeness it is fraught with a wreck of the steering wheel, which can provoke a skid.

The title of the most economical won the Nokian tires: the Golf wagged in them showed the best results on urban and country speeds.

Best braking and comfort on asphalt

Evaluation of comfort We continue on the secondary roads of the landfill, practically not different from many Russian trails: pits, stripped cracks, seams.

Gt Radial, Hankook and Nokian tires were quieter, and the most noisy - Firestone, which buzzes, how rolling across the asphalt gear. By smoothness ahead - the same GT Radial and Hankook, and the company was NITTO. The toughest - again Firestone, in detail transmitting vibrations from road irregularities to the floor of the body and even on the driver's seat.

The final exercises are an assessment of the brake properties on dry asphalt and wet. Tracks preliminarily cleaned up to dozen braking at non-verbal tires. Bremening on each set of test tires four to six times: on dry asphalt - from 80 km / h, on wet - from 60 km / h to save the protector from damage. Accounting speed, up to which the VBOX measuring complex produces a braking distance, is 5 km / h - at a smaller ABS admits a short-term blocking of the wheels, which adversely affects the accuracy of the results.

On dry asphalt, the shortest braking path, 30.3 meters, turned out on the gislaved tires, the longest on Bridge: 33.5 meters. The difference is 10.5%. On the wet in front of all again gislaved with an indicator of 17.8 meters, and the closing - nitto with a result of 21.7 meters, which is almost 20% weaker.

"Black" tests

On the asphalt confidently defeated the Gislaved Nord * Frost 200. The European tires Pirelli, Nokian and Goodyear are located behind him. Easterns made their way only to the fifth position, and took her GT Radial Icepro 3. The last couple from the European team: Continental took the sixth place in the "asphalt" list, immediately before the Nordman middle monophage. The leader of the "White" HANKOOK list on the asphalt, alas, could not rise above the tenth place. Close "Black" Rating Bridgestone and Nitto.

Top 13 final points

So, the victory with the result of 915 points won tires Nokian Hakkapeliitta 9. They are the most balanced - in all conditions will like all drivers, regardless of the preparation and style of the ride.

The second and third places were divided by Hankook Winter I * Pike RS 2 and Continental IceContAct 2, scored 905 points. What to say about Korean tires? The best result and in the snow, and ice, the most comfortable, economical, but - passing positions on the asphalt.

We recommend them to those who use mainly "white" roads. Continental showed the second result in the "white" tests, but in the rest of the nominations he made a middle snone. His best qualities will be shown on snowy and iced roads.

The fourth line of our rating is occupied by Pirelli Ice Zero - 888 total points mean that these are very good tires. Strong on the asphalt, will not let go on the snow and ice, they will help save fuel. Is that the comfort of driving leaves much to be desired.

Goodyear Ultragrip Ice Arctic (877 points) on the asphalt performed more than in ice and snow disciplines. These tires still have the right to be called very good, but slowly pass positions - they dropped into fifth, and for several years they occupied the third. But if you need all-terrain tires - this is the best choice.

For the brand of the second echelon, the sixth place (874 points) Nordman 7 tires and the title of very good can be considered an excellent result. Universal tires of the middle hand for any conditions, and in the snow can even please drifters.

Gislaved Nord * Frost 200 lost only four points to his direct competitor to Nordman. Indicators on the "white" roads are medium, but on the asphalt Gislaved - in the leaders.

This is the best choice for urban roads peeled from snow and ice. True, they do not shine efficiency and comfort.

From the eighth place, the eastern territory begins. Bridgestone BLIZZAK SPIKE-02 scored 847 points in the test - in our classification it is good tires. In the snow and ice look with middling, but they will not allow boring. For comfort and fuel economy are comparable to the "younger brother" Firestone Ice Cruiser 7, and on the asphalt even weaker.

At the ninth position - new Toyo Observe ICE-FreeZer Tires with 840 points. The unconditional advantages are the stability of the results on different coatings and a decent level of comfort.

Tens of Nitto Therma Spike closes with a final rating of 821 points. The same modest place is in the "white" ranking. These tires are economical, provide an average level of comfort ... and last place on the asphalt.

GT Radial tires scored 811 points. And found themselves on the last line of the ranking drawn up on the "white" roads. In the snow and ice on them permissible to move without a rush, and only on vehicles equipped with electronic assistants. But on asphalt roads, these tires will allow driving confidently and ensure a high level of comfort. Twelfth place and only 788 points - in Tires Firestone Ice Cruiser 7. According to modern standards, these are very weak tires for winter roads, not recommended for cars without ABS and stabilization system. It should be riding on them very carefully, without attempts to at least slip.

But on dry asphalt, they brake better than the related Bridgestone Blizzak Spike-02, and can compete with it in comfort and economy.

With a wallet

Good tires are a lot of money. How to find an optimal balance between the most important properties and price? You can focus on the "cost" of each score from a type of one or another. According to this parameter, GT Radial Icepro 3 is leading: each thousand rubles spent on this bus will result in 312 final scores. A little less profitable purchase - Nitto Therma Spike and Toyo Observe Ice-Freezer.

In the middle of the list - Tires Nordman 7 and Gislaved Nord * Frost 200. And closure the rating of "quality prices" Bridgestone Blizzak Spike-02, Continental IcecontAct 2 and Nokian HakkaPeliitta 9. It does not happen well. West invinciate? In our test, European tires turned out to be stronger than the eastern. In addition to Hankuk, none of the eastern tires fell into the first half of the "white" results. Why? In the countries of the East, the use of studded tires is prohibited - manufacturers create them for other people's markets. There is no rich eigenvery experience of such tires. Hankook began to be unconventional - attracted new products of experienced specialists from successful Western tire companies. After all, winter tires are an archent product balanced under completely different coatings (ice, snow, dry and wet asphalt) that require conflicting technical solutions. Oriental tire manufacturers will be able to compete with Western only when they understand this and implement this understanding in practice. Hankook is a bright example. In the meantime, the East can attract the buyer only with sweet prices.

Before the creators of the winter tires, it is worth a difficult task - they have to create a product capable of working in absolutely different conditions. After releasing the new studded model Therma Spike, Nitto approached the solution of this task almost closely

What are the requirements of the Winter Tire? Ideally, it is equally well to work on dry asphalt, and on a wet, both in the snow and on ice, and also when driving on puddles and dirt. Practically, it turned out during our test: under the wheels there was a wild meal out of water, snow and ice. What, what is it not possible for new thermal spike to demonstrate their talents?

Before starting the test, we will study the technical features of the novelties. There is a lot of interesting things. For example, Japanese engineers managed to make the composition of the mixture even softer, which led to an increase in the efficiency of the tire at low temperatures. In addition, the Nitto Therma Spike rubber mixture added a natural component from Walnuts shells. In addition to concerns about ecology, such a solution led to the fact that solid microparticles seem to be combined into ice, increasing the coupling and brake characteristics of the tire.

Special attention deserves a tread pattern. It is an asymmetrical - for winter tires such an advanced solution is quite unusual. Yes, and the form of the grooves from this model nitto is unusual: all lines broken, as if they painted an abstractionist. In fact, multidirectional grooves provide the so-called edge effect and with rectilinear motion, and in turns. This is especially important in the snow and ice - thanks to the strongly broken grooves, the rubber is better cling to a slippery surface.
We also worked on the strengthening of the tread blocks, pursuing two goals at once: improve controllability characteristics and reduce the likelihood of premature wear. In addition, the edges of some blocks were made by saws, which made it possible to achieve an additional increase in stability in turns and improving the adhesion in deep snow.

It was not without the newest 3D technologies. First, there are three-dimensional lamellas, allowing rubber to show excellent results on slippery surfaces due to a stable contact spot. Secondly, "locking" elements were added to them - a set of internal small depressions and bulges. When accelerating or braking, they closes, significantly increasing the rigidity of the blocks, which allows them to preserve their shape.

But perhaps the most interesting thing in the new product is spikes. We can say that they are real "stars". No, really. Let's start with the fact that everyone's base is made in the form of a five-pointed star, so engineers have tried to minimize the likelihood of metal elements. But the "claws" themselves have a cross-shaped form, remotely resembling an asterisk. This configuration ensures the contact of the spike with the surface is not in one, but at once in two points. Moreover, it works and when moving in any direction (forward or backward), and in turns, where such spikes are very effectively vague into the icing surface. It is interesting for their location on the surface of the tread: in the longitudinal projection of the spikes form 20 lines to ensure maximum efficiency.

At the very beginning of the test, there were contradictory feelings. On the one hand, nature presented a surprise behind a surprise - the temperatures of the temperature turned into a real mesh of snow, ice and wet asphalt. In addition, heavy low clouds hung over his head, which turned the surrounding nature in a dull gray picture. On the other hand, it is similar conditions that are not suitable for checking winter tires. So I had to distract from the gloom of the weather and concentrate on the behavior of the tires.

First of all, in the city drew attention to the noise level. Of course, a miracle did not happen: the characteristic rust of the studded tires still makes its way into the car's salon, even despite the very worthy noise insulation of Mitsubishi Outlander. But, of course, this applies mainly to the asphalt ride. In addition, objectively speaking, new nitto does not too spoil acoustic comfort. For example, listen on the road music or companion practically do not interfere. Perhaps the overwhelming majority of competing tires make up loud sound.

As for the riding comfort, there was no complaints at all. The smoothness of the Japanese model provides quite decent. With small cracks, these tires coped playing, thereby unloading the car suspension. Yes, and on major ughab, the elasticity of the tire helps to make the trip comfortable.

But the main surprise expected after leaving the semi-empty country highway. Rare pretty neighbors crawl over it, like a turtle. And no wise, because after several temperature surges, the coating turned into a bar of obstacles. Basically under the wheels wet asphalt, but no, no, and there is an island of a rolled snow or a mirror-smooth area of \u200b\u200bnaked ice. And here the tires showed themselves in all its glory - they would seem to them all. Therma Spike, as a real universal soldier, easily cope with all the tasks. And they do it so well that I slowly build a pace. A little faster, some more and more ... However, the crossover is still riding just as reliably and confident. I trial sharp braking - and there are no problems here. By the way, when slowing, drew attention to how confidently the car holds the trajectory.

Having imbued with confidence, I perform the following maneuver: with a set of speed I pass a gentle gear, where under the wheels and snow, and ice. Began carefully, but soon I increase the tempo. As it turned out, these tires and at lateral accelerations work is no worse than with a straightforward movement. True, as a result, I still overtook you in the ceiling of possibilities - from a certain point, the car began to learn to go into the skid. However, this happened at such a speed at which such a turn would not pass any sensible and appreciating his life driver.

After completing the test program, I can say: although Nitto Therma Spike has not done a revolution, they unequivocally raised the quality bar to a new level. So if you have selection of new winter shoes for the car, be sure to pay attention to these universal, high-quality and modern tires from Japan. They really can not only instill confidence in you on the winter road, but also save from many troubles.

© 2021 Bugulma-lada.Ru - Portal for car owners