Yokohama Iceguard Stud Ig35 reviews tests. Tests, testing and evaluation of the Yokohama Ice Guard IG35 tires. Objective reasons for lagging

Official information

Winter tires Yokohama Ice Guard 35 - Last Year's New Tire Market. Press releases of the Japanese company promised the wonderful behavior of the car in any situation. But in reality, alas, everything looks different.

This is what the manufacturer promised:

New high-tech Winter studded tire Yokohama Ice Guard IG35 with a directional protector was presented at the manufacturer's plant located in Japan. Yokohama engineers stated that the novelty is designed to ensure traffic safety on any, even highly snow-covered, coated with ice cortex roads and is designed to justify customer confidence due to high technology and excellent brand image.

The main advantages of the tire of Yokohama Ice Guard 35, which is indicated by the manufacturer:

1. Ensuring excellent car handling on snow-covered and iced roads through the use of unique 3D lamellas.

2. 3D lamellas with a multifaceted surface improve the characteristics on ice and snow, increasing the contact spot when the deviation and the edge effect without losing the stiffness of the blocks.

3. Minimizing spikes with protrusions around the planting opening.

4. Semiradial grooves - improve the output of snow, slush and water from the contact spot. Serial side grooves - Improve transverse stability, prevent perversal and slip

5. The improved composition of the rubber mixture almost completely prevents the deformation not only in the protector part, but also in the Schip planting opening.

At the same time, Japanese engineers themselves do not hide that for testing Yokohama Rubber Co. It uses one of the largest internal test devices simulating snow, ice and wet coating.

Test rubberYokohama Ice Guard 35

On the winter morning of the January day, the test was received by the Nissan Tiida hatchback, the Yokohama Ice Guard Stud IG35 195 / 65R15 winter tires. On the thermometer was -15 degrees Celsius, and on the roads the snow, slices of ice and naked asphalt - the right conditions for the test winter tires. First, the movement along the main streets of the city is a clean asphalt, which is not yet littered with snow and unemployed with reagents, that is, dry and clean. On such a road, the car goes quietly, gently and predictable. Assess the effect of tires tested in this context is not easy. Explicit tricks from Yokohama Ice Guard 35 is not observed, but explicit advantages too.

With changing the coating, the behavior of the car has changed. The road appeared on the road, from above covered with a thin layer of fresh ynei. In such conditions, the rubber protector quickly loses relief and becomes smooth. Recovered Snow Tall Grooves, Dirt and Ice Yokohama Ice Guard 35 V real life Not working absolutely: the car is unstable rides in a straight line even at the minimum speeds, fishing around and late reacting to teams. Braking is sluggish, acceleration is the same. Such behavior is characteristic of the friction tire, but Yokohama Ice Guard Stud IG35 is a studded model. Then why is it so helpless in solid snow?

The randral lies in the tire state. Almost half of spikes lacked on all four wheels, and those that remained, kept weakly and were planted deeply. On the front wheels of thorns, there is almost no left, and, with a fluent inspection, the Yokohama Ice Guard 35 tire more resembled immaculated, friction model. At the same time, the mileage of the tires, exactly as a car, was minimal - just over 1000 km, but the life of spikes turned out to be shorter. Of course, the fate of test machines is always more complicated by civilian. They try to squeeze everything. It is quite logical that the tires here are comparable to high loads. But in relation to Yokohama Ice Guard Stud IG35 a lot of reviews are written on the Internet. real ownerswho bought themselves these winter tires. All of them note the short life cycle of spikes, as the main disadvantage, from which all other rubber problems flow.

The deeper into the drifts, the more problems and torment. Yokohama Ice Guard Stud IG35 can not mascel the courtyards and forgotten streets of the city. Usually cars of this class, trained in other winter tires, are quite viable in such conditions.

It is noteworthy that Yokohama Ice Guard Stud IG35 - the model is not old. She appeared on the market automotive rubber By the winter season, 2011, that is, at the time of its release on the market, other models have already been present in the same price category, which have proven their consistency in the context of the Russian winter. A bright example is Nokian Nordman 4. Finnov, this model has been successful, but the Japanese of their Yokohama Ice Guard Stud IG35 was clearly not turned out.

After 1000 km of the run of the Yokohama Ice Guard 35, half of the spikes lost half of the spikes.

Finnish rubber manufacturers Model Nokian Nordman 4 has succeeded, but Japanese over their Yokohama Ice Guard Stud IG35 needed to work more.

Text: Roman Kharitonov

Claimed Rubber Characteristics Yokohama Ice Guard 35:


Speed
	Winter, studded
Price per 1 pc.	3400 - 3600 rubles.

According to the manufacturer's application, the widely unfolded central edge of the reinforced ribbons of the Yokohama Ice Guard 35 rubber improves maneuverability and stability on ice, wet and coating.

3D lamellas with a multifaceted surface improve the characteristics of the Yokohama Ice Guard 35 rubber on ice and snow, increasing the contact stain when the deviation and the edge effect without losing the stiffness of the blocks.

The three-dimensional design of Yokohama Ice Guard 35 is designed to increase the edge effect, and the protrusions around the hole are to help the spike hold.

For more reliable retention of spikes in the Rubber Yokohama Ice Guard 35, the holes of the new form are used.

Articles on the topic

Ssang Yong Actyon - Crossover or Pickup?

Ssang Yong. Actyon is the first SUV of the Korean company with the bearing body. Action is offered to customers in two bodies: crossover and pickup. Compared to the previous generation, the new Parketnik has every chance to conquer the love of buyers.

RuseFF auto chemicals: against corrosion!

We disassemble how to deal with the most frequent problemsassociated with corrosion of the car, with the help of modern auto chemical compositions Ruseff. Video instructions.

Ruseff against oxides!

We continue a series of publications devoted to the solution of regular problems faced by car enthusiasts. At first we looked at the difficulties arising from the winter operation of the car, then told how to deal with corrosion. This material is devoted to the protection of the vehicle electricity.

Total "Something Actual Questions about Oil

Our country is rich in climatic conditions, and in traveling around the country as a tourist or at work often there are situations when you need to move from one climatic zone to another. At the same time, there is a logical question, what to do with oil and is it necessary? The head of the Technical Department Total Vostok Roman Korchagin is responsible for questions.

Popular Test Shin Yokohama Ice Guard Stud Ig35 +

81.35 points from possible 100

Reviews of car owners about tires Yokohama Ice Guard Stud Ig35

Yandex Market

Normal model

Advantages: Price, tread geometry
Disadvantages: The main enemy is a pitch. The ice is not very kept, the snow porridge is 40 km to the skid goes easily and slipping with the slightest pressure on the gas on top of the usual.
Comment: Delivered from the previous owner. I don't like the tires ... From the rut, it doesn't just push out, but throws away! Moreover, it is sharp that once a little in the bumpman was not removed. Snow porridge and ice does not like. I am already at 40 km / h, on the ice, the feeling like sleds are going with a small slide and try to slow down the legs \u003d) I do not recommend, my still for the season should be definitely, maybe more ... I will suffer

Excellent model

Advantages: It copes well with both Hollyeda and with snowy drifts, low noise, competitive price.
Disadvantages: Not yet.
Comment: I bought an I-Pike Hankuk on replacing. Very pleased. The season is suitable for both the city and for a parcel. It was noisy for the village. Be healthy on asphalt, the same tires just whispers. You will play your role that the spikes are played, which does not affect its winter properties. For two years, not a single spike has not lost, although anything happened. He began to flee away after the second winter. I do not regret that I took this model, four cylinders along with installation cost 10280 rubles. Recommend.

Bad model

Experience: more than a year

Advantages: Beautiful tread pattern, spikes do not fly out
Disadvantages: Very soft, no course stability, clarity in turns, although the machine and predictable. The main drawback is a weak sidewall, just - the cones immediately get out. He darned into the tireage to carry them, despite the fact that in winter I go a little. Doubtful coupling qualities. About operating experience below.
Comment: Cheap yokohama, 8Tyr. For the kit purchased in 2013. Parameters 175/65 / R14. Machine - Toyota AE101, front-wheel drive, automatic, 160 forces. For my meager experience of its operation (4 winters, of which 2 almost completely stood the car in the garage), the overall mileage of thousand 5 seats. One of the wheels broke through, descended. Bare is not an option, only welding. On the second a year ago the bump got out, you can say spontaneously, because Visually damage was not - strengthened and brewed in a tire fitting, but the tubercle remained in this place. And on the third wheel a small bump, good in size is not growing yet. I try to ride carefully, but it does not help with our roads. Smell-another miss anyway. Regarding the coupling properties on the snow and the ice, it is a feeling that the car is 100,500 forces - you just give the brass - grinds and does not go, possibly too narrow. Due to the high profile and softness, the car swings decently, you feel the eyes that the car goes on the desired trajectory, and the body is shed to the left-right. Rebuildings and a keyboard, respectively, too languid (it is on dry asphalt, in the winter it is not particularly charged, you can fly away) noise, as well as any winter hips, compare on your car yet with nothing. The tread wear is practically no, but it is not relevant to my mileage. Manufacturer - Philippines, just in case. Can levak some.

Good model

Experience: more than a year

Advantages: Soft, good rowing.
Disadvantages: Spikes fly out. The second season is 50% left by the end

Excellent model

Experience: more than a year

Advantages: Good grip with an expensive, the second season there is no problem.
Disadvantages: not detected
Comment: In general, positive sensations from rubber.

Terrible model

Experience: a few months

Advantages: On dry asphalt and in the snow inhibits adequately
Disadvantages: Rubber with autocata pumping spikes
Comment: There is no lamella, the solid central strip on the ice does not hold at all, the spikes jump off. Now, if I do not, the resulting is good. But when the road is sprinkled with reagents and then do not clean - this is necessary for such a soap kaha, it is impossible to ride: on the turns at 20 km / h, it strives to the opposite to leave. On the drive there is a review and video, on YouTube, too, as I spent 50 meters from the speed of 50km / h (I experimented the pedal to the floor)

Good model

Experience: a few months

Advantages: Soft enough. Not noisy. Spikes are all in place.
Disadvantages: With sharp braking, slightly takes on ice.

Sources

Sources comply with companies that independently produce tire comparison based on a constant technique, which includes the maximum number of tire quality criteria, and put objective estimates According to the results of the tests for a group of similar tires, depending on the type of use.

This database includes only those sources that meet these criteria. These criteria are also applied for each source test.

Sources used to determine tire technical indicators:

Results of tests published in specialized editions.
The data obtained according to Regulation (EU) 1222/2009 "On Tire Marking in relation to the effectiveness of fuel consumption and other essential parameters." Or estimates used in labels automotive tires (Mobs *) in the absence of official data.
Data published by independent test laboratories.

A detailed list of sources (with the exception of the EU Regulations 1222/2009) used to estimate the rating of each product is attached to the publication.

Evaluation scheme

The final assessment consists of 9 basic indicators, which are updated with 4 other basic indicators for winter tires.

Basic indicators are divided into 5 groups: 3 - for summer tires, 2 - for winter tires.

Each basic indicator occupies a different weight coefficient in its group based on the degree of significance in the category.

Below are groups of indicators and their basic indicators:

Method of calculation

Each basic indicator is estimated according to the following principle:

Evaluation of 10 points is assigned a tire that received best result For a certain test.
Evaluation of other tires decreases in proportion to the obtained mean-square deviation of the discriminant.
All results exceeding 9 times this rms deviation is estimated to be estimated 1.

If the source uses its own rating system (which is not based on a 10-point system), in this case, linear transcoding is performed.

The final assessment of the basic indicators will be based on the average arithmetic estimates obtained from the results of each test.

Note: Tests conducted by road journals or specialized organizations are usually based on the most common sizes in the market. Despite the fact that tire performance may differ slightly depending on the size, we preferred to assign an estimate of the entire size panel of a specific tire model.

The first and second place is occupied by the long-standing competitors - Nokian and "Continental", almost annually updating their products. Prices (3700 rubles) are almost the same, but since Nokian Hakkapeliitta. 7 (in Russian execution) by the amount of the indicators a little better Continental ContiCecontAct, then the price / quality ratio of "Russian Finns" (3.9) is a little more attractive than that of the "Germans" (4.0).

Another product domestic production Michelin X-Ice North 2 is tightly on the third position, although the model is no longer new. The price tag is slightly lower - 3300 rubles. Because the price / quality ratio turned out to be slightly tastier: 3.6.

Older Gislaved Nordfrost 5 (3200 rubles) in value is fourth. However, in our tests, he typing 892 points occupies a sixth position and in terms of price / quality ratio (3.6) is on a par with Mischlen. In our opinion, the people of this model buys more in the habit, taking into account the good reputation of the predecessors. And the real price should be even lower.

The next price in the price rating is Bridgestone Ice Cruiser 7000 (2900 rubles). Fresh model is very modest characteristic for our winter. Therefore, it takes only an eighth position with the result of 829 points, although according to the price / quality ratio, equal to 3.5, lies very close to the "Michelin" and "Gislaved." Apparently, for a well-promoted brand, our buyers are ready to pay more. However, many appreciate the heightened hernifestability, helps confidently ride on the roads. Our opinion - these tires should be cheaper.

ICOGUD ICOGUD IG35 products (2800 rubles) are traditionally slightly cheaper "Bridgestone", although according to characteristics it is almost no inferior (828 points and ninth place in the final list). Accordingly, the price / quality ratio (3.4) is more attractive. We consider the price tag again overestimated. Buyers with reverence belong to japanese brandHowever, on its tires is: "Made in the Philippines." Another reason for popularity is to participate in WTCC racing.

Winter Carving Edge from Pielli for 2700 rubles. In terms of cost only in the seventh place. But following the results of the test, "Italians" scored 912 points and entered the first five rating of SP. Very good result, and the price / quality ratio is less than that of all top tires - 3.0. Respect! By the way, problems with loss of ships went to the past.

Cheaper you can buy Korean Kumho I'zen KW22 and Russian Nordman 4 - 2400 rubles. "Russian" on the results of the test is clearly attractive: 913 points and fourth position, and therefore the ratio of price / quality is 2.6. A very interesting and advantageous product.

Cordiant Sno-Max of domestic development is even cheaper - 2200 rubles. Position in the test (852 points and seventh place) worthy of respect - the model surpassed import tires from the eastern manufacturers. Value for money - 2.6.

The cheapest tires are Kama Irbis (or 505), they can be bought in less than 2000 rubles. a piece. In the test, they were not shown even up to 800 points, typing only 776. The last century cannot be called them - the model appeared six years ago, simultaneously with Gislaved NF 5, but according to the characteristics, it is clearly not corresponding to the current level. I foresee the question: why did not test the latest models of Kama EURO 518 and 519? Alas, in the most popular winter dimension of 175 / 65R14, they are simply not released by limiting the old model.

TEST RESULTS
Note: So far lack test results in some disciplines.

Table of expert estimates

Final result: 944 points The debut took place in 2008, from 2009 - in Russia. At the beginning of this year, once again upgraded in the composition of rubber and geometry of spikes. Coupling properties are very well balanced. Longitudinal on ice and snow are almost the best. Cross on ice - very good, better only from "Gislavda". On the snow - above average. On the snow-covered road, it goes smoothly, without comments, it is sensitive to the direction adjustment. Slightly improve informativeness on the steering wheel - and you can put nine points. In the turns, the predetermined trajectory of the front wheels is clearly prescribed, and the rear clings are slightly worse, causing insignificant excess turning. But add enough to add gas, and the car is screwed into the turn of any curvature. Deep snow is not afraid, easy maneuver. If the car rested the bumper into an irresistible snowdrift, it will not be difficult to get out. On asphalt, too, do not hide. At high speed, it goes smoothly, inhibit the hare and wet well. There is no comments for acoustic comfort and smoothness. By fuel economy, the leading position holds both at 90 and at 60 km / h. Speaking of spikes close to the limit of reasonable. Not a single spike. Excellent brake qualities and best overclocking in the snow and ice, high transverse clutch on the snow and passability. Good term stability on any winter Road. High level of comfort, economical. Not noted. Verdict: add confidence and driving on any winter roads. Assist to save fuel at any speed.

Final result: 927 points They saw the light in 2010 and immediately appeared in Russia. The coming year has updated the rubber and the design of spikes. According to exemplary coupling properties, there are leading positions in all exercises on ice and snow, with the exception of the ice circle. It is not quite smooth in the winterer, tangible pulling the car into a deeper snow, slightly slide on the transverse slopes. Steering wheel Not enough informative. Managed not bad, but with some features. In steep turns, the speed is limited by the demolition of the front axle, and in gentle, more high-speed turns show a tendency to a rescued drift, which is better to parry at small corners, not giving to develop. The snowdrifts are not afraid, but require a certain driving style: do not like intensive bucking, preferring the movement of the sweat. They are not always able to rescue the car from a snowy cape by reverse. On the asphalt, the course holds without comments. Brokes on dry and wet road very well, passing forward only child "Gislaved". Comfortable - no noise noise. But little shook the car on irregularities. Fuel consumption is modest, along with "Mischlen", "Nordman", "Pirelli" and "Iokoham". During the tests, the speech of the spikes has not changed, a good quality. The best braking and acceleration on the snow and ice, transverse clutch on the snow. Very good cross grip on ice and braking on dry and wet asphalt. Minor comments to the course stability on the snow-covered road, to the passability in the deep snow and smoothness. Verdict: Low on any winter roads.

Final result: 921 score Appeared in 2009. From the same moment on russian market. Have a good balance of coupling properties. Overclocking on a winter road confident in any modes, slipping when the speed set does not reduce its effectiveness. On the snow-covered road, exactly, stable, not paying attention to the thickness of the snow cover, irregularities and transverse slopes, are sensitive to the direction adjustment. Behavior when turning turns on snow and ice is understandable and well predictable; Easy insufficient turning (mild demolition of the front in the limit) together with immediate responses to the steering steering. In deep snow, feel confidently, in the move prefers a bounce. Even if the car crashes on the belly, in most cases will still take out. The asphalt will not be saved. At good speed in a straight line, go smoothly, without delay, respond to the course adjustment. Braking on dry and wet road is good. Comfortable. Quite quiet, except that there is a slightly different way on the asphalt of different quality. There is no complaints about the smoothness. Fuel consumption is modest. Speaking of spikes normally, its growth rate during testing is insignificant. This speaks about the good quality of the misfortune. Good braking and acceleration, transverse coupling properties on snow and ice. Small fuel consumption. Not noted. Verdict: give confidence on any winter roads and winter off-road.

Final result: 913 points The model was established in 2009, from that time is sold in Russia. The composition of the mixture was updated this winter. For the coupling properties of the tires are similar to Mishlenov. They are good on ice and snow along longitudinal and transverse coupling properties, and at the rearrangement turned out to be even faster than their progenitor "Nokian". The straight is slightly floating, demanding a constant direction adjustment - kept in voltage. IN fast turns Machine is easier to control the gas than the wheel: the reset is responsible for screwing, when adding the radius increases. Snow tick overcome without problems. Reversely are confidently chosen from any snowdrift. Feature: Predict soft, without slipping Trogan, from the spot. And on the go, you can get gas out gas as much as you like, it even helps. More gas is better! On the asphalt line the same features as on the snowy road. Minor deviations from a given direction requiring constant infringement. Braking on wet asphalt is good, on dry - average. Noise level is higher than more expensive relatives, and the smoothness of the same. Fuel consumption is modest at any speed. Speaking of spikes and changes in its magnitude normal. During the test test, the tires lost three spikes from the front tires, but it is hardly critical. Good brake quality on snow, ice and wet asphalt, overclocking on snow and ice. Excellent cross grip in the snow and permeability. Good handling on the winter road, modest fuel consumption. Minor comments to the course stability on a snowy road and asphalt, to noise. Verdict: suitable for any winter roads and winter off-road.

Final result: 912 points Created in 2008, since then they have repeatedly upgraded them. The last time - at the beginning of this year. The brake properties in the snow are the best, on ice mediocre, and the transverse clutch on that and on other coatings is also average. Acceleration is good, and on any coating. However, it is effective only when driving in a latitude. On the snow-covered straight bus surprised by a clear rate, sensitive asphalt reactions and low raw beam angles when the direction is adjusted. Any turns pass with pleasure - to understand the car helps a dense, informative steering wheel and immediate reactions, as well as close to neutral turning. Deep snow is better to overcome the move. Upon the tire of the tire fails slightly, although the tendency to self-concealing does not show. The back of the car is chosen confident. On the asphalt the same clear course, as on summer tires. Tight steering wheel and small angles when correction of the course. Braking on wet coating average, dry - frankly bad. Tires are voiced by shifting coating and grungy asphalt, diligently transmit pushes from irregularities. Fuel consumption is modest. Speaking of spikes is normal, the change in its magnitude is not critical. Lost only one spike. Best braking in the snow, good overclocking on ice and snow, cross grip on ice. Modest fuel consumption, excellent handling and course stability on any road. Weak brake properties on a dry road. Minor comments to the patency in deep snow and comfort. Verdict: They will show their best qualities in highway modes on any winter roads.

Final result: 892 points Another one of the old people - the model was created back in 2006, since then sold in Russia. This winter has updated the mixture. Longitudinal coupling properties in the snow and ice are average, but the transverse on the snow are very good, and on the ice - the best. It is necessary to accelerate on the verge of bucking - so more efficient. On the snow-covered road, it goes smoothly, but "zero" on the steering wheel is empty, informativeness is missing. Comments to charture of minor. There is no complaints to the initial phase of the claim, but on the arc, the speed is limited to demolition, then driving - this ambiguity is noticeably straining. In deep snow require minimal slip, the latitude are confident. Back selected easily. On the asphalt, the course is smooth, without comments, but also without sings. In brake disciplines, the best and dry surfaces and wet. The comfort is standard, although it is noted on the asphalt and dense snow. Fuel consumption is above average at any speed. Speaking of spikes is normal, during the tests, the average value has grown within the limits of allowed, that is, the quality of the misfortunes is good. But during the tests of the tire lost five spikes. Last year, only two fell. The trend is alarming: before, he had not been noticed for "histmouncement". The best brake properties on dry and wet asphalt, the best transverse clutch on ice, very good - in the snow. High level of comfort, good course stability on any road. Medium overclocking on any coating, fuel consumption at any speed above average, minor comments to manageability, loss of five spikes. Verdict: It will show their best properties in the first place on well-purified roads, but do not save on iced and snow-covered.

Final result: 852 points The debut took place in 2008. On the icing road against the background of medium acceleration and transverse clutch, inhibit mediocre. In the snow, the align is more logical: weak acceleration and satisfactory transverse clutch are completely rolled with good braking. Decent acceleration is only in a latitude. On the snow-covered straight, digs from side to side. It is quite difficult to handle, since feedback is no informative. In rapid turns, the speed is limited by demolition. Moreover, the slide is tightened, the recovery of the clutch has to wait long. According to the snowdrifts, they are swaying confidently, moving in any modes, do not require driving in any modes. On asphalt, it is possible to quickly drive with great care, - swimming within the band forces the driver to constantly adjust the course. Significant corners of the steering wheel and its insufficient informativeness are prevented. Braking on dry and wet coatings good, the results are comparable to the "Nokian" shown. Comfort does not differ: loudly noisy, thumps on irregularities, voiced the coating change. About saving fuel will have to forget. Fuel consumption at a speed of 60 km / h medium, at 90 - elevated. Speaking of thorns within the normal range, the rates of its growth too. Lost spikes are not. Good braking in the snow, on dry and wet asphalt, permeability. Mediocre brake quality on ice, overclocking in the snow, cross grip on ice. Increased fuel consumption at 90 km / h, low course stability on asphalt. Verdict: For snow-covered, slightly iced and purified roads.

Final result: 829 points Like "Iokohama", the most recent model. The year of birth they have one, 2010, but Bridgestone in Russia sold only since 2011. On ice is very uncertain overclocking, satisfactory brake properties and cross-clutch. In the snow, the longitudinal grip is frankly weak. On acceleration loses the course with the slightest slip, in which they break very unexpectedly. We go along the snow-covered road Exactly, there are no comments to the course stability. It is useless to rush in the turns on the winter road: the speed on ice is limited by a drift, coming suddenly and requiring immediate adjustment. In the snow, the machine straightens the trajectory, and the turn slides overly long. In the snowdrifts, the movement is not sufficient enough, it is better not to be touched, the thread is chosen quite confident. On the asphalt slightly floating, directional delays and low informativeness interfere with the direction of direction. Brokes well and dry, and on wet asphalt. It is noisy very much, an unpleasant hum and howl is made on asphalt and even on ice. Any road irregularities respond with excessive vertical accelerations. Fuel consumption elevated at any speed. The magnitude of the speakers of spikes and the pace of its change is normal. Lost spikes are not. Good braking on dry and wet asphalt, course stability on a snow-covered road. Weak brake qualities on the snow, overclocking on the snow and ice, cross grip on the snow. Increased fuel consumption, strong noise, complex handling on the winter road.

Final result: 828 points On ice, longitudinal coupling properties are very weak, transverse - medium. In the snow, the balance is a bit different: overclocking and transverse properties are satisfactory, and the braking is bad. You can face the machine from the place with a bounce, then it is better to stop it, as you manage to dial the speed, only moving the sweat. On the snow-covered road, the car is growing greatly, strives to leave the trajectory toward the deep snow. In turn behavior, the behavior is clearer, the steering wheel is dense, understandable, initial reactions are immediate. However, the speed on any coating is limited to the drift. Deep snow does not like, with difficulty moving forward, thread get out of the snow, it is unlikely to succeed. On asphalt, too, hurry should not be rushing: digging, requiring constant adjustment, large steering angles and "rubber" stabilization with fading rear axis in one, then in the other direction. On a dry road, it stops very well, on the wet brake path the largest. Comfort leaves much to be desired - strongly shake on any irregularities. It was noisy even on ice and in the snow. Fuel consumption is small. The spikes, in our opinion, are unnecessarily bueled, the low coupling properties on the ice are partially explained by this. The growth rate of speakers in the norm, not lost. Good braking on dry asphalt, moderate fuel consumption. Mediocre braking properties on the snow and ice, the weakest overclocking on ice and braking on the wet asphalt. Low term stability on a snow-covered road and asphalt, bad permeability. Verdict: for purified, partially snow-covered and slightly iced roads.

Final result: 823 points Appeared in 2008, a year later began to be sold in Russia. Longitudinal coupling properties on iced road weak, transverse - average. In the snow, overclocking satisfactory, braking and transverse clutch are weak. Troce from the place is better "whisper", with acceleration permissible slightly bounce. On the snow-covered straight line go smoothly, without comments. In the snow, the behavior of the car is not very clear - demolition outside or drift and care. The transition to sliding sharp and unexpected. Slip length. On Ice, the behavior is more stable: only skid, but very sharp. In deep snow, falling at the Trokhan and strive to bury. It is better to get a battery, move - with a light slip. It is not necessary to get involved in the movement in a virgin: you can go there, where to get out of the reverse move. On the asphalt straight, it is well held, however, when the direction is adjusted, delays in reactions are strained. Brake properties on wet asphalt average, and dry is the worst. He is greatly buzzing and spent, on irregularities, they are tangible. Fuel consumption is small at any speed. Speaking of spikes and its change within the normal range. Small fuel consumption, good course stability on a snow-covered road, satisfactory - on asphalt, good smoothness. Mediocre braking properties on ice and snow, transverse clutch on the snow. The weakest brake features on dry asphalt. Complex handling on the winter road, increased noise, weak passability. The verdict: suitable for purified, partially snow-covered and slightly iced roads.

Final result: 776 points Together with "Gislaveda" was born in 2006. On Ice coupling properties - both transverse, and longitudinal are the weakest. In the snow, the longitudinal grip is simply no. And the transverse is very weak. Overclocking is problematic, it is necessary not to break the wheels in the stopping, otherwise it is impossible to dial the speed. On a snowy road, you should go slowly: the car is growing hard on irregularities, seeks to go to the roadside, in deeper snow. The steering wheel is empty and non-informative, as in computer racing. In the corners, the car goes, as it swings, as if the steering wheel is disconnected from the wheels. It can break out or break into the skid and finish the movement of turn. Considerable lags exacerbate the situation, huge branch turning angles and slipped slides. Movement on the snowdrifts is possible only in the dash, without stopping. An attempt to move leads to selflessness. Reverse move moves uncertainty. On the asphalt float, requiring constant adjustment. Brokes on the wet very weakly, on dry medium. For comfort better forget. Strong noises, shocks and vibrations even where the road looks smooth. Fuel consumption at 60 km / h above average, 90 - elevated. The protrusion of the spikes and the rate of its growth in permissible limits. Lost spikes are not. Medium brake properties on the snow and dry asphalt. The weakest brakes on ice, acceleration and transverse clutch on ice and snow. Weak brake properties on wet asphalt. Problem challenge on slippery coating, poor course stability on a snow-covered road. Loud noise, very tight tires, increased flow Fuel. Verdict: not allowed for well-purified roads.

Final result: 944 points

The debut took place in 2008, from 2009 - in Russia. At the beginning of this year, once again upgraded in the composition of rubber and geometry of spikes.

Coupling properties are very well balanced. Longitudinal on ice and snow are almost the best. Cross on ice - very good, better only from "Gislavda". On the snow - above average. On the snow-covered road, it goes smoothly, without comments, it is sensitive to the direction adjustment. Slightly improve informativeness on the steering wheel - and you can put nine points.

In the turns, the predetermined trajectory of the front wheels is clearly prescribed, and the rear clings are slightly worse, causing insignificant excess turning. But add enough to add gas, and the car is screwed into the turn of any curvature. Deep snow is not afraid, easy maneuver. If the car rested the bumper into an irresistible snowdrift, it will not be difficult to get out.

On asphalt, too, do not hide. At high speed, it goes smoothly, inhibit the hare and wet well. There is no comments for acoustic comfort and smoothness.

By fuel economy, the leading position holds both at 90 and at 60 km / h.

Speaking of spikes close to the limit of reasonable. Not a single spike.

Excellent brake qualities and best overclocking in the snow and ice, high transverse clutch on the snow and passability. Good term stability on any winter Road. High level of comfort, economical.

Not noted.

Verdict: add confidence and driving on any winter roads. Assist to save fuel at any speed.

Final result: 927 points

They saw the light in 2010 and immediately appeared in Russia. The coming year has updated the rubber and the design of spikes.

According to exemplary coupling properties, there are leading positions in all exercises on ice and snow, with the exception of the ice circle. It is not quite smooth in the winterer, tangible pulling the car into a deeper snow, slightly slide on the transverse slopes. Steering wheel Not enough informative. Managed not bad, but with some features. In steep turns, the speed is limited by the demolition of the front axle, and in gentle, more high-speed turns show a tendency to a rescued drift, which is better to parry at small corners, not giving to develop.

The snowdrifts are not afraid, but require a certain driving style: do not like intensive bucking, preferring the movement of the sweat. They are not always able to rescue the car from a snowy cape by reverse.

On the asphalt, the course holds without comments. Brokes on dry and wet road very well, passing forward only child "Gislaved". Comfortable - no noise noise. But little shook the car on irregularities.

Fuel consumption is modest, along with "Mischlen", "Nordman", "Pirelli" and "Iokoham".

During the tests, the speech of the spikes has not changed, a good quality.

The best braking and acceleration on the snow and ice, transverse clutch on the snow. Very good cross grip on ice and braking on dry and wet asphalt.

Minor comments to the course stability on the snow-covered road, to the passability in the deep snow and smoothness.

Verdict: Low on any winter roads.

Final result: 921 score

Appeared in 2009. From the same moment on russian market.

Have a good balance of coupling properties. Overclocking on a winter road confident in any modes, slipping when the speed set does not reduce its effectiveness.

On the snow-covered road, exactly, stable, not paying attention to the thickness of the snow cover, irregularities and transverse slopes, are sensitive to the direction adjustment. Behavior when turning turns on snow and ice is understandable and well predictable; Easy insufficient turning (mild demolition of the front in the limit) together with immediate responses to the steering steering.

In deep snow, feel confidently, in the move prefers a bounce. Even if the car crashes on the belly, in most cases will still take out.

The asphalt will not be saved. At good speed in a straight line, go smoothly, without delay, respond to the course adjustment. Braking on dry and wet road is good. Comfortable. Quite quiet, except that there is a slightly different way on the asphalt of different quality. There is no complaints about the smoothness.

Fuel consumption is modest.

Speaking of spikes normally, its growth rate during testing is insignificant. This speaks about the good quality of the misfortune.

Good braking and acceleration, transverse coupling properties on snow and ice. Small fuel consumption.

Not noted.

Verdict: give confidence on any winter roads and winter off-road.

Final result: 913 points

The model was established in 2009, from that time is sold in Russia. The composition of the mixture was updated this winter.

For the coupling properties of the tires are similar to Mishlenov. They are good on ice and snow along longitudinal and transverse coupling properties, and at the rearrangement turned out to be even faster than their progenitor "Nokian". The straight is slightly floating, demanding a constant direction adjustment - kept in voltage. IN fast turns Machine is easier to control the gas than the wheel: the reset is responsible for screwing, when adding the radius increases.

Snow tick overcome without problems. Reversely are confidently chosen from any snowdrift. Feature: Predict soft, without slipping Trogan, from the spot. And on the go, you can get gas out gas as much as you like, it even helps. More gas is better!

On the asphalt line the same features as on the snowy road. Minor deviations from a given direction requiring constant infringement. Braking on wet asphalt is good, on dry - average. Noise level is higher than more expensive relatives, and the smoothness of the same.

Fuel consumption is modest at any speed.

Speaking of spikes and changes in its magnitude normal. During the test test, the tires lost three spikes from the front tires, but it is hardly critical.

Good brake quality on snow, ice and wet asphalt, overclocking on snow and ice. Excellent cross grip in the snow and permeability. Good handling on the winter road, modest fuel consumption.

Minor comments to the course stability on a snowy road and asphalt, to noise.

Verdict: suitable for any winter roads and winter off-road.

Final result: 912 points

Created in 2008, since then they have repeatedly upgraded them. The last time - at the beginning of this year.

The brake properties in the snow are the best, on ice mediocre, and the transverse clutch on that and on other coatings is also average. Acceleration is good, and on any coating. However, it is effective only when driving in a latitude.

On the snow-covered straight bus surprised by a clear rate, sensitive asphalt reactions and low raw beam angles when the direction is adjusted. Any turns pass with pleasure - to understand the car helps a dense, informative steering wheel and immediate reactions, as well as close to neutral turning. Deep snow is better to overcome the move. Upon the tire of the tire fails slightly, although the tendency to self-concealing does not show. The back of the car is chosen confident.

On the asphalt the same clear course, as on summer tires. Tight steering wheel and small angles when correction of the course. Braking on wet coating average, dry - frankly bad. Tires are voiced by shifting coating and grungy asphalt, diligently transmit pushes from irregularities.

Fuel consumption is modest.

Speaking of spikes is normal, the change in its magnitude is not critical. Lost only one spike.

Best braking in the snow, good overclocking on ice and snow, cross grip on ice. Modest fuel consumption, excellent handling and course stability on any road.

Weak brake properties on a dry road. Minor comments to the patency in deep snow and comfort.

Verdict: They will show their best qualities in highway modes on any winter roads.

Final result: 892 points

Another one of the old people - the model was created back in 2006, since then sold in Russia.

This winter has updated the mixture. Longitudinal coupling properties in the snow and ice are average, but the transverse on the snow are very good, and on the ice - the best. It is necessary to accelerate on the verge of bucking - so more efficient.

On the snow-covered road, it goes smoothly, but "zero" on the steering wheel is empty, informativeness is missing. Comments to charture of minor. There is no complaints to the initial phase of the claim, but on the arc, the speed is limited to demolition, then driving - this ambiguity is noticeably straining. In deep snow require minimal slip, the latitude are confident. Back selected easily.

On the asphalt, the course is smooth, without comments, but also without sings. In brake disciplines, the best and dry surfaces and wet. The comfort is standard, although it is noted on the asphalt and dense snow.

Fuel consumption is above average at any speed. Speaking of spikes is normal, during the tests, the average value has grown within the limits of allowed, that is, the quality of the misfortunes is good. But during the tests of the tire lost five spikes. Last year, only two fell. The trend is alarming: before, he had not been noticed for "histmouncement".

The best brake properties on dry and wet asphalt, the best transverse clutch on ice, very good - in the snow. High level of comfort, good course stability on any road.

Medium overclocking on any coating, fuel consumption at any speed above average, minor comments to manageability, loss of five spikes.

Verdict: It will show their best properties in the first place on well-purified roads, but do not save on iced and snow-covered.

Final result: 852 points

The debut took place in 2008.

On the icing road against the background of medium acceleration and transverse clutch, inhibit mediocre. In the snow, the align is more logical: weak acceleration and satisfactory transverse clutch are completely rolled with good braking. Decent acceleration is only in a latitude.

On the snow-covered straight, digs from side to side. It is quite difficult to handle, since feedback is no informative. In rapid turns, the speed is limited by demolition. Moreover, the slide is tightened, the recovery of the clutch has to wait long. According to the snowdrifts, they are swaying confidently, moving in any modes, do not require driving in any modes.

On asphalt, it is possible to quickly drive with great care, - swimming within the band forces the driver to constantly adjust the course. Significant corners of the steering wheel and its insufficient informativeness are prevented. Braking on dry and wet coatings good, the results are comparable to the "Nokian" shown. Comfort does not differ: loudly noisy, thumps on irregularities, voiced the coating change.

About saving fuel will have to forget. Fuel consumption at a speed of 60 km / h medium, at 90 - elevated. Speaking of thorns within the normal range, the rates of its growth too. Lost spikes are not.

Good braking in the snow, on dry and wet asphalt, permeability.

Mediocre brake quality on ice, overclocking in the snow, cross grip on ice. Increased fuel consumption at 90 km / h, low course stability on asphalt.

Verdict: For snow-covered, slightly iced and purified roads.

Final result: 829 points

Like "Iokohama", the most recent model.

The year of birth they have one, 2010, but Bridgestone in Russia sold only since 2011.

On ice is very uncertain overclocking, satisfactory brake properties and cross-clutch. In the snow, the longitudinal grip is frankly weak. On acceleration loses the course with the slightest slip, in which they break very unexpectedly. We go along the snow-covered road Exactly, there are no comments to the course stability. It is useless to rush in the turns on the winter road: the speed on ice is limited by a drift, coming suddenly and requiring immediate adjustment.

In the snow, the machine straightens the trajectory, and the turn slides overly long. In the snowdrifts, the movement is not sufficient enough, it is better not to be touched, the thread is chosen quite confident.

On the asphalt slightly floating, directional delays and low informativeness interfere with the direction of direction. Brokes well and dry, and on wet asphalt.

It is noisy very much, an unpleasant hum and howl is made on asphalt and even on ice. Any road irregularities respond with excessive vertical accelerations.

Fuel consumption elevated at any speed.

The magnitude of the speakers of spikes and the pace of its change is normal. Lost spikes are not.

Good braking on dry and wet asphalt, course stability on a snow-covered road.

Weak brake qualities on the snow, overclocking on the snow and ice, cross grip on the snow. Increased fuel consumption, strong noise, complex handling on the winter road.

Final result: 828 points

On ice, longitudinal coupling properties are very weak, transverse - medium.

In the snow, the balance is a bit different: overclocking and transverse properties are satisfactory, and the braking is bad. You can face the machine from the place with a bounce, then it is better to stop it, as you manage to dial the speed, only moving the sweat.

On the snow-covered road, the car is growing greatly, strives to leave the trajectory toward the deep snow. In turn behavior, the behavior is clearer, the steering wheel is dense, understandable, initial reactions are immediate. However, the speed on any coating is limited to the drift. Deep snow does not like, with difficulty moving forward, thread get out of the snow, it is unlikely to succeed.

On asphalt, too, hurry should not be rushing: digging, requiring constant adjustment, large steering angles and "rubber" stabilization with fading rear axis in one, then in the other direction.

On a dry road, it stops very well, on the wet brake path the largest. Comfort leaves much to be desired - strongly shake on any irregularities. It was noisy even on ice and in the snow.

Fuel consumption is small.

The spikes, in our opinion, are unnecessarily bueled, the low coupling properties on the ice are partially explained by this. The growth rate of speakers in the norm, not lost.

Good braking on dry asphalt, moderate fuel consumption.

Mediocre braking properties on the snow and ice, the weakest overclocking on ice and braking on the wet asphalt. Low term stability on a snow-covered road and asphalt, bad permeability.

Verdict: for purified, partially snow-covered and slightly iced roads.

Final result: 823 points

Appeared in 2008, a year later began to be sold in Russia.

Longitudinal coupling properties on iced road weak, transverse - average. In the snow, overclocking satisfactory, braking and transverse clutch are weak.

Troce from the place is better "whisper", with acceleration permissible slightly bounce. On the snow-covered straight line go smoothly, without comments. In the snow, the behavior of the car is not very clear - demolition outside or drift and care. The transition to sliding sharp and unexpected. Slip length.

On Ice, the behavior is more stable: only skid, but very sharp. In deep snow, falling at the Trokhan and strive to bury. It is better to get a battery, move - with a light slip. It is not necessary to get involved in the movement in a virgin: you can go there, where to get out of the reverse move.

On the asphalt straight, it is well held, however, when the direction is adjusted, delays in reactions are strained.

Brake properties on wet asphalt average, and dry is the worst. He is greatly buzzing and spent, on irregularities, they are tangible.

Fuel consumption is small at any speed. Speaking of spikes and its change within the normal range.

Small fuel consumption, good course stability on a snow-covered road, satisfactory - on asphalt, good smoothness.

Mediocre braking properties on ice and snow, transverse clutch on the snow. The weakest brake features on dry asphalt. Complex handling on the winter road, increased noise, weak passability.

The verdict: suitable for purified, partially snow-covered and slightly iced roads.

Final result: 776 points

Together with "Gislaveda" was born in 2006.

On Ice coupling properties - both transverse, and longitudinal are the weakest. In the snow, the longitudinal grip is simply no. And the transverse is very weak. Overclocking is problematic, it is necessary not to break the wheels in the stopping, otherwise it is impossible to dial the speed.

On a snowy road, you should go slowly: the car is growing hard on irregularities, seeks to go to the roadside, in deeper snow.

The steering wheel is empty and non-informative, as in computer racing. In the corners, the car goes, as it swings, as if the steering wheel is disconnected from the wheels. It can break out or break into the skid and finish the movement of turn. Considerable lags exacerbate the situation, huge branch turning angles and slipped slides.

Movement on the snowdrifts is possible only in the dash, without stopping. An attempt to move leads to selflessness. Reverse move moves uncertainty.

On the asphalt float, requiring constant adjustment. Brokes on the wet very weakly, on dry medium. For comfort better forget. Strong noises, shocks and vibrations even where the road looks smooth.

Fuel consumption at 60 km / h above average, 90 - elevated. The protrusion of the spikes and the rate of its growth in permissible limits. Lost spikes are not.

Medium brake properties on the snow and dry asphalt.

The weakest brakes on ice, acceleration and transverse clutch on ice and snow. Weak brake properties on wet asphalt. Problem challenge on slippery coating, poor course stability on a snow-covered road. Loud noise, very tight tires, increased flow Fuel.

Verdict: not allowed for well-purified roads.

It is not necessary to compare the results of studded and untapped tires, as they were tested on different days, in different weather conditions, and the ratio of the coupling properties of those and other tires depends on the weather very much. At one temperature, "spikes" are in front, with the other - soft "velcro". We found it a few years ago: SP, 2009, № 1

Now imagine the participants.

15 inches argued

Self dear tires - Nokian for 4150 rubles, but they are the best - Hakkapeliitta R ( russian production) Together with Michelin X-Ice 2 shared first place. Value for money - 4.5.

Slightly cheaper, for 4100 rubles. You can buy ContivikingContact 5. Our results suggest: and these tires are in place. True, in terms of price / quality ratio (4.6) this purchase is slightly less profitable.

But Michelin X-ICE 2 in price costs is on the best position: 3900 rubles. Value for money, equal to 4.2, the most attractive in the first triple. We believe that the cost of this tire is underestimated, because there are already in the market new model - Michelin X-Ice Third Generation. She was officially presented by last winter outside of Russia, postponing the official presentation of the novelties on us for almost a year.

In the fourth place Goodyear UltraGrip Ice + 3560 rubles. For a piece (we believe, the price is overestimated - fee for high brand). Value for money - 4.1.

The fifth financial rating should be Bridgestone Blizzak Revo Gz - 3520 rub. Tire is cheaper for the smallest. Earnings in our tests of 892 points, it turned out to be in fourth place with an even more attractive price / quality ratio, equal to 4.0.

Very close at the price (3500 rubles), but already on the sixth place the next tire - Pirelli Winter IceControl. The final table also occupies a sixth place with 846 points. We believe that it should be sold slightly cheaper: now the price / quality index is 4.1 - like a stronger "Houdier".

Yokohama Ice.Guard IG35 for 3400 rubles. At the seventh place, although the test showed the eighth result by typing only 820 points. Once they buy, it means there are those who are ready to pay for the inscription Made in Japan.

Nizhnekamskaya Viatti Brina scored 816 points and ranked ninth. Tire with a foreign name for the price of only 2600 rubles. Bye must be well sold, local marketers believe. We wish them good luck.

The cheapest bus is Cordiant Polar SL for 2500 re. And in the test she took the seventh place, even ahead of the Japanese product. In our opinion, 826 points at a ratio of price / quality, equal to 3.0, is the result, worthy of attention.

All tables open in full size over the click of the mouse.

16-inch "Shipovki"

Nokian Hakkapeliitta 7 for 6600 rubles. Ahead of the rest of the world. Expensive, but deservedly, since these are the best tires in our test: 929 points. The price / quality ratio is also "leading" - 7.1.

In second place ContiCecontact. The difference with the winner of 200 rubles. ("Conti" costs 6400 rubles) and 4 points give a decrease in the index price / quality to 6.9.

The third place is the novelty of Goodyear UltraGrip Ice Arctic, - rightly, since the tire is clearly from the leaders. It can be bought for 5,500 rubles.

A little cheaper sell Michelin X-Ice North 2 - for 5400 rubles. The cost is even slightly understated, because in our Xin 2 tests scored 923 points, the price / quality ratio is the most attractive in the leading troop test: 5.9.

Another 100 rubles. Cheaper Gislaved Nordfrost 5 (5300 rub.). According to the results of the test, the tire scored 905 points, taking the sixth place. Value for money 5.9 Equally Mishlenovsky. Loves our people "Gislaved", because there is no money regrets.

On the sixth place Bridgestone Ice Cruiser 7000 for 5250 rubles. In our tests, this model was able to take only the eighth place by typing 855 points. The price / quality ratio is 6.1 more than that of Mishlen and Gislavda.

At the seventh position of Pirelli Winter Carving Edge, which can be bought for 5200 rubles. We recommend these tires, because in the tests they were in fourth place by typing 918 points. And with such a cost indicator price / quality is the most attractive in the first six test: 5.7.

Next to Yokohama IceGuard IG35 - and, as usual, with a slight gap at a price with Bridge: Sale for 5100 rubles. The place in the price sheet is close to busy in our test, but the price / quality ratio is overestimated: 6.1.

At all in another price category (4500 rubles) Sell a novelty Hankook - I-Pike RS. A decent tire, which made a big step forward from the previous model and scoreing 886 points. Almost close to the binding of 900 points, which distinguishes very good tires from others. Index Price / Quality is 5.1 - It is worth seeing.

Nearby no less worthy Nordman 4 Russian production, they offer only 4,400 rubles, that is, in two thirds of the price of a leading older brother. Meanwhile, in our final list "Nordman" ranks fifth (!) Position. The ratio of price / quality and manit - 4.8. Good suggestion.

For 4000 rubles. You will find Cordiant Polar 2. The place in the price rating corresponds to the resulting formation, although the price / quality ratio (5.0) is less attractive than that of Nordman.

Closes the parade of popular tires "Kama-Euro 519": only 3500 rubles, - last place And in our test. Buying a tire with a ratio of price / quality equal to 4.3, will not be ruined for the modest budget.

Friction tire rating 195/65R15

1-9_no_copyright

Based in 2010, in our test participate for the first time.

Weak on ice in all directions - in acceleration, turns and braking. In the snow, more points are: worse than others hold turns, weakly accelerate, but brake well - along with "Nokian"! Course stability on a snow-covered road leaves much to be desired: the car is experiencingly growing, demanding infringement. Hold the right direction prevents low informativeness - the steering wheel in an effort is almost empty. In fast turns, the first reaction is good, although the rotation angles are vigorous. The transition to slip soft, asked the trajectory is kept, however, and here the driver grieves overly lightweight, empty steering wheel.

The snowdrifts do not like, if necessary, it is better to overcome them, without turns and stops. Amend the direction refuse, the Trogan is possible only in a latitude. During the slip, they strive to bury up, retreat reluctantly. On the asphalt straight line, the car goes even when accelerated. At constant speed floats, requiring a tireless adjustment, which responds to unpleasant pouring the rear axle.

Brokes on a dry road weakly, on wet - worse than all. Uncomfortable: loudly noisy, with a growing speed more and more. Transmit shakers from medium and large road irregularities, vibrate on small. The fuel is valid at any speed.

2-9_no_copyright

3-8_no_copyright

Created in 2008, in our market appeared in 2009, but in the test of SC takes part for the first time.

On Ice, the transverse clutch and overclocking the weakest. Braking average, and it pleases. But on the snow and braking, and overclocking is worse than all other dough participants, although in the turns are held at the road. On the snow-covered straight straight, they grow a bit, they take away the car from a given direction, tightening into deeper snow. Handling mediocre: The car does not listen to the steering wheel and strives to straighten the trajectory, slipping out the viragee. The skid occurs only if provoked it, but is well compensated.

In deep snow, moving insecure, and only with a certain degree of bucks. Reward refuses, slides in a rings or there, where less resistance. On asphalt goes smoothly, but when the direction is adjusted. At small angles, the steering wheel is very sluggish, but with an increase in the angle of rotation, the car sharply changes the direction to the larger angle than was required.

Braking is stable and dry, and on wet asphalt, the brake path of the average size. Comfortable: quiet on any road, only on the comb slightly itch. Transfer shuddering and small shoes from small irregularities. Extra fuel is not consumed, but also does not save.

4-8_no_copyright

5-7_no_copyright

Production and sales have begun in 2009.

On Ice, the behavior of an unbalanced - middle hand overclocking, weak grip in the turns and the weakest braking. But on the snow, everything is exactly, the grip is average in all directions. On the snow-covered road, it seems and carry the car exactly, and the steering wheel in the "zero" is dense, understandable - but the back takes over the side to the side, and this does not attach confidence. In turn behavior is unstable. In the initial phase, an unpleasant drift occurs, which manages to compensate for the addition of gas. With the cooler of the steering wheel, his informativeness decreases sharply, literally falls. The matter will end, no one knows - you have to fight either with demolition, or with a drift.

The same uncertainty and in deep snow. Move well only on the verge of bucking. It is especially dangerous to slip at the time of the Troggy: leads to an injection. On the other hand, maneuvers are given without tension, the car is chosen confidently with reversing. On the asphalt goes exactly, the reaction when the direction is corrected is clear. But here the rear axle does not give the driver to relax, having twisted after action steering. This gives a car delaying excess turning.

Braking and dry, and on a wet road is weak. You can not call the tires - publish an increased hum. Transmit shakers on the body from medium and large irregularities, vibrate into small. Fuel consumption is above average at any speed.

8-7_no_copyright

6-6_no_copyright

Created in 2009, at the same time began selling in Russia, in 2011 modernized.

On ice, braking and transverse grip are medium, and overclocking is weak. In the snow, on the contrary, overclocking the middle, braking is weak, and the transverse coupling properties are the lowest, along with "VIATTI". On the snow-covered road, it goes smoothly, without reacting to different thickness of a snow blanket, - Course stability from Pielli is traditionally good. Handling, too, without comments: The steering wheel is dense, understandable, reactions are clear. The transition to the slide is soft, the trajectory can be set and adjust both the wheel and gas. There is practically no drift, in the limit the car all starts to crawl out.

Deep snow does not want to overcome. Forward moving reluctantly, even in motion trying to bury. Well, though thread chosen. On the asphalt remind summer tires - Dense steering wheel in the okolonul zone, excellent informativeness and clear follow-up to the specified direction.

Braking is surprisingly weak on the wet and the weakest on dry asphalt. The noise is increased, high vibration trucks - the company firm pays little attention. It is not very willing to roll - fuel consumption elevated at any speed.

9-6_no_copyright

7-5_no_copyright

Burned in 2009, in the market are present from 2010.

Deservedly enter the top five. They differ from those who stayed behind, good balance: all the characteristics are not leadership, but even on any of the coatings that will meet in winter time On our roads. For example, on ice and in the longitudinal, and in transverse directions showed average results. It is not so good on the snow: overclocking and cross grip is medium, but slightly leads to weak braking. At high speed through the snow, go smoothly, but not enough informativeness on the steering wheel. Lack of confidence and when moving in turn. At the entrance, a tangible delay in reactions makes it overly rotate the ram. For this reason, in the initial phase of turning, the car is in demolition, demanding to reset the gas. And on the arc turn, knocks off to break into a skid, which, fortunately, is easily parched.

The drifts are overcome without tension, go forward confidently, do not burst under the trokhan, but they don't like strongly. On the asphalt, slightly digging on the transverse irregularities, respond to a slightly delay. There is no complaints about the noise of noise, even on the rough asphalt rolls quietly. But on convex irregularities, it is decently shaken by the car and transmit vibrations from the seams, cracks and micronether roads.

Inhibit medium, without showing preferences with dry or wet coating. At a speed of 60 km / h, it is helped to save fuel, at 90 km / h look from this point of view.

10-5_no_copyright

11-4_NO_Copyright

The model is the designer "Gudira", created in 2009, on our market is sold since 2010.

Good on ice in acceleration, brake properties and transverse clutch are only medium. In the snow, overclocking and transverse grip are medium, and braking is weak. Only "Iokohama" stops worse. On the snowy road go smoothly. Experts noted not only confident deduction of the direction, but also an informative steering wheel, as well as immediate reactions to the course adjustment. In fast turns, the speed is limited to the soft demolition of the front axle, which is eliminated by the cooler steering or a slight decrease in speed. Barley high informativeness.

The drifts are overcome reluctantly, forward moves uncertainly, they turn badly. Reverse move moves more confidently, allow you to get out of the snow trap. According to the asphalt, they are practically smoothly, they grow out a bit on transverse irregularities, and when the direction is adjusted slightly.

Brokes on wet coverage well, and on dry stops the best. Pretty comfortable - go on any coating softly and quietly, except that a little hissing on a snowy road. The fuel consumption is average at 60 km / h, and at 90 km / h increased.

13-4_NO_Copyright

12-3_no_copyright

Released since 2008, at the same time they began to be sold in the Russian market.

During this time, the mixture was not upgraded again. On Ice show average results in braking and cross-clutch, and accelerates well. But behind the snow clings better than all: in the appropriate exercises were leading. But the term stability slightly stripped: small difficulties appear when trying to adjust the direction of movement. With each small turn of the driver's steering wheel, a slower reaction and shallow, but long-term drift. In rapid turns, reactions are prevented in reactions and low beam informativeness, which leads to increasing drift with prolonged stabilization.

In deep snow, turn the machine into the tractor. Very confident touch, moving and maneuver in any modes, without fearing the bounce. On the asphalt, slightly float, are affected by the side wind, are noticeably delayed on corrective steering steering. Transmit vibrations from small irregularities, tightly pass the road joints, forcing the car to shock. They are noisy, it is unpleasant to crunch and buzz in slippery turns when they find, for which it is hooked.

Brokes on wet asphalt Best of all. Yes, and on dry show good results. At a speed of 60 km / h, the most economical (along with the "Houdier", "Michelin" and "Nokian"), at 90 km / h do not require superfluous.

14-3_no_copyright

15-2_no_copyright

Created in 2008, since then and sold.

A good balance of coupling properties on all covers that can be found on the winter road. On Ice, the coupling properties are smooth, regardless of actions and modes - in turn, during overclocking, when braking. In the snow, good transverse clutch and acceleration, but braking average. In a straight line, they go smoothly, without a hint of the desire to be used from a given direction, accurately react to the steering wheel when the course is adjusted. In turns behave clearly, without problems and surprises. Clearly prescribe the turns, allow you to adjust the radius with the wheel or changing the fuel supply.

In the snowdrifts feel at home. Feelings are similar to those that you get from "Continental." Confidently row, bend in any modes, maneuver without difficulty. On the asphalt goes smoothly, bribe clear reactions comparable to the behavior of summer tires.

Brake well, regardless of whether dry asphalt or wet. Comfortable: only slightly voiced by tractor trail and rough ice. About the smoothness of the course comments are also not. Economic in urban speeds are not abused by fuel and at 90 km / h.

17-2_no_copyright

16-1_no_copyright

Created in 2008, since then they are almost annually being upgraded.

On the ice - the coupling properties in all disciplines in all disciplines: in braking, during acceleration and in a circle. In the snow, the clutch is very good: when overclocking and in turn, the best, along with the "continental", in the efficiency of braking is slightly inferior to it - the second result. In a straight line "White" road go smoothly, without requiring adjustment. According to the controllability, similar to Bridgestone and Pielli: as clear reactions, the car also obediently changes the trajectory when manipulating the wheel or gas. The same good stabilization after sliding provoked by the driver.

Deep snow is better to overcome, drowned the gas pedal to the floor. True, in this mode, risks are clicked into such a snowdrift, from where without shovel or extraneous help do not get out. Although during the tests it was not needed - the car was always reversed. The asphalt goes exactly, but the experts noted small delays when adjusting the course.

Brokes well on wet coating and medium on dry. As for the comfort, there are minor comments - the noise level on the uneven road is somewhat increased, vibrations from small irregularities are transmitted. For any speed, fuel consumption is the lowest in the test.

18-1_no_copyright

Studded tire rating 205/55R16

19-11_no_copyright

Created in 2008, from that time sold. In 2010, the composition of the rubber mixture is upgraded.

Nevertheless, against the background of other winter tires "Kama-Euro 519" looks weak. On the ice, the coupling properties are very low, worse only from the "Cordian". In the snow, the clutch is also more than modest. The only consolation is the balance of coupling properties is quite even in all directions: it slows down, accelerates and keeps the road in the turns weakly. On the snow-covered road, it is better to go slowly: the car is digging from side to side. In a slippery turn, the behavior of the ribbon: the car breaks down into demolition, then in the skid. More or less, the steering wheel is only on the rolled snow. On ice, even at a small speed, it breaks into the skid. Slides on any coating for a long time. Keep the car under control interfere with very large corners of the steering wheel and significant delays in reactions.

In deep snow, it is not quite confident. At the time of the Trogan, it is better not to stop. With the wheel twisted towards the wheels, better than right. Reversely is chosen without problems. On the asphalt growing hard on the road. Correquency direction interferes with very large steering angles, significant delay and low informativeness, and even unpleasant torturing the rear axle.

Braking on wet asphalt is weak, on dry is the weakest. On Ice and asphalt loudly spent the protector. Very tough - passes the shocks from medium irregularities and vibrations from small.

22-11_no_copyright

20-10_no_copyright

They saw the light in 2009, but in our test appeared for the first time.

Overflowed spikes make the bus almost helpless on ice - neither accelerate nor turn or stop. In the snow holds a little better. The transverse clutch is closer to the middle, although overclocking is weak, and the braking is the weakest. The course in the snow is quite even, only small lying with a change in depth are noted. On Ice coupling properties are subjectively assessed as very bad. It is not necessary to sharply twist the ram, otherwise the car refuses to rotate. If you still managed to turn, the arc is waiting for a skid. In the snow, the speed is limited to a sharp breakdown in the skid. Parious it prevents the lack of informativeness of the steering wheel and low delays in reactions.

In deep snow, not quite confidently moving. There are no pronounced preferences in motion modes, it is well pulling the car with a small bucking. Reversely go confidently. The asphalt goes smoothly, but when the direction is adjusted, a slight infringement of the rear axle and the lack of informativeness of the steering wheel are intermitted.

Braking average and dry road, and wet. Comfort does not indulge: buzzing loudly loudly, shake the body on convex irregularities, pushed on medium, transmit vibrations into small. Fuel consumption at 60 km / h increased, at 90 km / h above average. The spikes are not held very reliable: during tests, the protrusion value has changed to three "dozens".

23-10_no_copyright

21-9_no_copyright

Pretty fresh tires were created in 2010, from that time sold in Russia.

But in our test they lit up for the first time. On Ice coupling properties in all directions are average. In the snow behave less confidently: braking and transverse grip weak, overclocking the most sluggish, along with Bridgestone. On the snowy road, they grow a little. In the turns affect not enough high coupling properties - the machine is completely slid out.

Sugro not for these tires: in deep snow stuck, as they are called, in a flat place. During the Trogan, fail, strive to bury. Reverse move moves uncertainty. According to the ideal asphalt, it is going to smoothly, but on our roads is not often found. Therefore, a constant adjustment of the direction is required, which is complicated by delays in reactions and unpleasant swelling of the rear axle.

On a dry road, the car stops reluctantly, and braking on the wet is the weakest. Very tough: shocks from irregularities are transmitted to the floor and the seat, vibrations occur on the steering wheel. Loudly noise and buzz with spikes. Fuel consumption average at any speed. The spikes hold securely, there are no losses, but the size of the protrusion is more than modest: reliably cling to such spikes per ice and tight snow will not be able.

24-9_no_copyright

25-8_no_copyright

Created in 2009, but in the Russian market appeared late, in 2010.

On Ice coupling properties: medium and in braking, and in turns, and in acceleration. In the snow go less confident than on ice. The braking is weak, overclocking the most sluggish, like the "Iokohama", the transverse clutch is also the lowest. On the snowy road, they dig a bit, but they do not leave the trajectory. Slow reactions to steering steering. In rapid turns, the speed is limited to a long demolition. In the slide of the front axis, the car on the trusted steering wheel does not react.

In deep snow, it is confidently touched and moved, but only a dashing. It is necessary to check the wheels, the thrust is lost and the car immediately stops. According to asphalt, they go smoothly, retain the specified course. But when you need to adjust the direction of movement, the driver strains the rear axle and is not an informative steering wheel.

When measuring the brake route again, "Iokohama" was again. As with her, braking is weak and dry, and on wet coverage. It is not sufficiently comfortable: they are transmitted to the body to shock from irregularities, loudly noisy with a tread and spikes, even at high speed. Fuel consumption at 60 km / h increased, at 90 km / h above average. Speaking of spikes and the rate of increasing the protrusion. Loss for test time is not.

28-8_no_copyright

26-7_no_copyright

New in the Russian market. As they say, with heat from the heat.

On Ice coupling properties high, reasonable balance. Brake and transverse clutch are good, overclocking medium. In the snow, too, quite strong. Longitudinal coupling properties are good, transverse - mid-level. On the snowy road, they grow slightly, but they do not leave the trajectory. There is a lack of informativeness of the steering wheel and a small delay when adjusting the direction of movement. Frams in slip turns are rescued, the car slides longer than I would like, but the clutch restoration is soft and smooth.

In deep snow, it is not entirely confidently moving, when they slip at the time of the start, a tendency to self-paging is shown. Reversely go confidently. On the asphalt make the car swim through the strip. A wide "zero" is interfered, delays in reactions, winding the rear axle and insufficient informativeness.

Brokes weakly, and on dry asphalt, and on wet. Remarks regarding comfort: small vibrations from small irregularities and increased general noise, typical of the studded tires. At a speed of 60 km / h fuel consumption below average, at 90 km / h - the most economical. The magnitude of the speakers of spikes and the rate of increasing the protrusion is normal. During the dough, the loss of thorns was not.

29-7_no_copyright

27-6_no_copyright

The most "mature" tires in our test.

Made from 2006, from the same time sold in Russia. On Ice boasts a good balance: inhibit and turn well, accelerates medium. In the snow, coupling properties in any direction are medium - also good. On the snow-covered straight goes smoothly, without requiring infringement. In the corners on the ice and the rolled snow are pleasing to clear reactions and a very soft transition to sliding. However, on the loose snow on the arc, a sharp drive arises, requiring the driver of clear steaming actions.

Deep snow does not complain, they are confidently moving only on the freshly made muffling. If the snow is slightly tight, you can only drive, you can only drive, without slipping. According to the asphalt straight line, the car is exactly, the reaction to the change in the course is immediate, except that informativeness on the steering wheel is not enough.

Braking is just shine: both on the wet, and on dry asphalt tires stop perfectly. The noise background is elevated, as in most "riding", and there is no claims to smoothness - all road irregularities are well smoothed. The most voracious at any speed. The magnitude of the speakers of the spikes and the pace of its growth in the test time is optimal. Lost a couple of spikes from the front wheels.

30-6_no_copyright

31-5_no_copyright

Released since 2009, from the same time sold.

Figure Tread - Heritage tires nokian. Hakkapeliitta 4. Different with a mixture composition and spikes with a round core. In our tests participate for the first time. On Ice, braking and transverse clutch medium, nice overclocking. In the snow, the behavior is more confident: the longitudinal coupling properties are good, and the cross-clutch is the most reliable. On the snow-covered straight straight and the front axle, and the rear, reacting to the density of snow. At low angles, the turning of the Baranki marked insufficient informationity. In the turns you can go rapidly - clear reactions, the behavior is clear. The speed is limited to a slight drift, which is easily compensated by the steering or the addition of gas.

Summills are not afraid: it's enough to add gas, and the car will go there where the steering wheel turns. Reversely is chosen without problems. On the asphalt goes smoothly, but when the course is adjusted, the delay in reactions and the empty steering wheel is tangible.

Brokes on dry asphalt medium, on wet - good. Loudly noise with a tread and spikes, especially from 40 to 60 km / h. The smoothness of the stroke can be called good, do not be small vibrations from small irregularities. Fuel consumption average at any speed. The magnitude of the speech of spikes and its increase during tests is close to the optimum. Lost spikes are not.

34-5_no_copyright

32-4_no_copyright

Based in 2007. From 2008 sold in Russia.

Periodically, they update the design, spikes and composition of the mixture, leaving the "face" unchanged. The latest innovations allowed Karving to join the leading group. On ice, longitudinal coupling properties are medium, and the cross grip is the highest. In the snow, the coupling properties are good in all directions. On the snow-covered road hold the course canceled. The car goes as an arrow and sensitively reacts even to small turns of a dense, highly informative beam. Turns are prescribed with a light. Clear, understandable management, sensitive reactions to the slightest steering wheel. In the limit, the speed is limited to a soft and smooth drift, which can be paid off by a small addition of gas or turning the steering wheel. Slide is fast, but gently stabilizes.

Suggesis overcome easily, when starting, do not bury, go and dirty, and with a bucking, easily maneuver. On the asphalt goes smoothly, the correction direction helps a clear "zero".

Brokes on wet coverage medium, on dry well. Traditionally, they do not care comfort: noisy, as if the plane flies, shake on any irregularities, as if they are thrown. Most likely, the low level of comfort is a kind of fee for the pleasure of driving a car on the winter road. Fuel is consumed middle at any speed. The magnitude of the spikes and the rate of their growth in the test time is optimal. There are no losses.

35-4_no_copyright

33-3_no_copyright

In the Russian market are offered since 2009.

The only of today's leaders use spikes with a circular core. On Ice longitudinal coupling properties medium, transverse - good. In the snow, the alignment of a little different: the longitudinal grip is good, and the transverse one is the middle hand. On the snow-covered road carry the car smoothly and stable. Reactions when correction of the course - without comments. In turns, the behavior is clear and understandable. The speed is most often limited to a mild demolition, but the car reacts well to the coat of steering and tries to keep the specified trajectory.

Even in slides, it does not come out from under the control of the driver. You can not only flash snow drifts through, but also to maneuver in them, stop and fed again. If I stopped the car, I snatched back and went further. It is always possible to get out of the thread. On the asphalt, the term stability is good, "zero" is clear, the steering wheel is dense - the tires are practically like summer.

Brokes on dry asphalt well, on wet - medium. The noise level is increased, on solid coating, the roar of spikes is clearly heard, especially in the range of 60-90 km / h. The smoothness of the course without comments - any irregularities are good. Fuel saved in all high-speed modes - and at 60, and at 90 km / h. Speaking of spikes and the rate of change in the magnitude of the protrusion normally. During run-in and tests, no spike is lost.

36-3_no_copyright

37-2_no_copyright

Relatively fresh model that appeared in 2010.

From the same year it is sold in Russia. It differs from other tires "diamond" shape of spikes. On Ice coupling properties are good in all directions. On the snow, the same is the longitudinal, and the transverse grip at a high level. On the snow-covered road allow you to go quickly, carry the car smoothly. But informativeness on the steering wheel is insufficient. In the turns prevail the demolition of the front axle. The skid, if such comes, manifests itself softly and smoothly and is eliminated without much difficulty.

In deep snow, it goes well only with intensive bounces, but this mode is inex-informative. Wrive down - and the reverse does not help. On asphalt goes smoothly, the steering wheel is dense, "zero" is clear, reaction when adjusting the direction immediate.

Basin on the wet asphalt is better than the rest, the average results are shown on dry, along with "Gislaved." Loudly noisy spikes on a solid coating - both on ice, and on asphalt, especially loudly from 70 to 90 km / h. Pretty hard: transmit vibrations from road irregularities to the floor of the body, seat and ram. Fuel consumption average at any speed. Speaking of spikes within the optimal value. Spikes are held in rubber very reliable.

40-2_no_copyright

38-1_no_copyright

Presented at the end of 2008, sold from 2009.

Constantly being updated, which allows them to hold in the lead. On Ice demonstrated the best longitudinal coupling properties, transverse - medium. On the snow - the best overclocking, good braking and the holder in turns. On the snow-covered road go smoothly, without comments. The steering wheel is dense, the reaction is clear. In turns, the speed is limited to a soft, helping drift, which is easier eliminated by a small addition of gas. Even in slides, the car listened to the driver teams, restores the trajectory gently and smoothly.

In deep snow, they are moving confidently, they are well maneuver, they are drunk without desire to bury. Any mode: from the professional movement of the sweat, without turning the wheels, to the "blonde" gas in the floor. Very well chosen by reverse. According to the asphalt, the movement is smooth, but when adjusting it is unpleasant to wind the rear axle.

Braking on dry asphalt is weak, on wet - average. Comfort is not ideal: the obvious noise of spikes on the asphalt and smooth ice, shocks from road irregularities, primarily convex. Economic at any speeds. The magnitude of the spikes is close to the limit of reasonable. Nevertheless, the average protrusion during testing has changed only by 0.1 mm, which means that the spikes in the rubber hold it reliably.

41-1_no_copyright

39-0_no_copyright

New, preparing for sale this year.

The final points we could not calculate, because in braking in the snow Ice Arctic beat the best serial tire, which we accepted in the calculations for the "base". On Ice high longitudinal coupling properties, and transverse - medium. On the snow - super bridge, very good overclocking and medium transverse coupling properties. On the snow-covered road, they grow slightly, with a delay reacting to the direction adjustment. In rapid turns, behavior is ambiguous. In the initial phase, at the stage of entering the turn, there is a tangible delay in reactions, leading to the demolition of the front axle. After restoring the clutch, already on the arc, the likelihood of the occurrence of driving, which is compensated and the wheel, and the addition of gas at the same time. After sliding, the clutch recovery occurs quite sharply, provoking a shooting skid to the other side.

The concepts of "deep snow" for these tires does not exist. Help the car for challenges from the snow captivity never needed. On the asphalt is noticeably floating from side to the side, requiring constant adjustment. Very wide "zero", delay on steering steering.

Brokes on wet asphalt well, on dry - medium. Pushed on medium irregularities, heavily buzzed with a tread and spikes. The magnitude of the speech of spikes is at the limit. However, changing the protrusion during test time in just one "top ten" suggests that the spikes are fixed firmly.

42-0_no_copyright

In detail about the notation and classification of tires can be found

Vadim ship, Yuri Kurochkin, Evgeny Larin,

Anton Mishin, Andrei Forms,

Valery Pavlov and Dmitry Tests.

Thank you for the technical support of AvtoVAZ auto-trail staff,

togliatti company "Volgashintorg",

as well as tire manufacturers

we submitted their products for test.

Test rubberYokohama Ice Guard 35

Claimed Rubber Characteristics Yokohama Ice Guard 35:

Articles on the topic

Ssang Yong Actyon - Crossover or Pickup?

RuseFF auto chemicals: against corrosion!

Ruseff against oxides!

Total "Something Actual Questions about Oil

Sources

Evaluation scheme

Method of calculation

15 inches argued

16-inch "Shipovki"

Friction tire rating 195/65R15

1-9_no_copyright

2-9_no_copyright

3-8_no_copyright

4-8_no_copyright

5-7_no_copyright

8-7_no_copyright

6-6_no_copyright

9-6_no_copyright

7-5_no_copyright

10-5_no_copyright

11-4_NO_Copyright

13-4_NO_Copyright

12-3_no_copyright

14-3_no_copyright

15-2_no_copyright

17-2_no_copyright

16-1_no_copyright

18-1_no_copyright

Studded tire rating 205/55R16

19-11_no_copyright

22-11_no_copyright

20-10_no_copyright

23-10_no_copyright

21-9_no_copyright

24-9_no_copyright

25-8_no_copyright

28-8_no_copyright

26-7_no_copyright

29-7_no_copyright

27-6_no_copyright

30-6_no_copyright

31-5_no_copyright

34-5_no_copyright

32-4_no_copyright

35-4_no_copyright

33-3_no_copyright

36-3_no_copyright

37-2_no_copyright

40-2_no_copyright

38-1_no_copyright

41-1_no_copyright

39-0_no_copyright

42-0_no_copyright

Editor's Choice